IKN

Take physic, pomp

A word on silver (from IKN528)

This piece discussing the potential for a silver breakout and what I planned to do before and after the event appeared in The IKN Weekly edition of two weekends ago, IKN528 dated July 7th, 2019. Another example of the difference between the blog and the weekly (where I actually get some work done), I’m publishing it on the open blog because from where I’m sitting it’s really hard to get a balanced view on this most contentious of metals, all the “silver sucks” versus “silver to the moon” shouting just gets on my nerves. Charts as appeared nine days ago, one company name removed.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

A word on silver

A lot of people are now pointing to silver as
the place to be, with newsletter writers, columnists and mining radio show
hosts all banging the table hard on the inevitable rise in silver that will
make us all rich, so let’s have a re-cap of the IKN Weekly coverage on the
metal this year. In the fundies note IKN513
dated March 24th entitled, “Regarding the Price of Silver in 2019” I laid out my own case
for an improved price of silver this year. Based on fundamentals (instead of
hope), the piece examined supply and demand characteristics of silver and came
to its conclusion, repeated here:

“There are never any guarantees, but on balance and after looking at the sector
from several different angles this week I’m fairly certain that the bottom in
the price of silver is in and downside risk is minimal. This isn’t due to lack
of demand from its main customers as industries of all sorts, electronics
makers, solar panel makers and people who like to wear shiny things on their
fingers, ears and necks are buying the metal as per normal. The demand slump
comes from the investment community, silver is now totally out of fashion and
being puked back into the market at a rate only seen at the height of the
financial crisis, ten years ago. That’s the contrarian signal I look for.”

That fundies note got a small update in IKN516
dated April 14th, in which the argument was repeated (and noted the
potential for the price of silver to move more quickly than I’d thought). With
that in mind, here’s the 2019 YTD comparative chart for silver (SLV proxy)
compared to gold (GLD):
 

So let’s check on the IKN513 conclusion
paragraph:

  • The bottom of the silver price was NOT in at the
    time, we had to wait for late May. Also in IKN517 I posited that silver may
    start its rebound earlier than I’d imagined in the first piece, so that
    was wrong, too.
  • Then again, the line about “downside risk
    minimal” seems to have held. Yes we dropped some more, no the drop didn’t
    last and we’re now back at U$15/oz.
  • If silver stackers are coming back into fashion
    (and they are getting the pep talk from all sides of the precious metals
    fanclub), as noted in the main body of IKN513 that would probably be
    enough to tip the balance back to bullish.

It’s hardly an inspiring price performance (and
the reason I set against gold is to show silverbugs what they’ve been missing),
but flatline after three months isn’t a disaster either and there are signs
silver is waking up. However, there’s also this:

The gold/silver ratio for the past five years
has been one-way traffic, with just the period in early 2016 to alleviate the
pain for longs. There’s a lot of talk about that early 2016 period today, the
recent gold move being compared to what we saw back then and the way silver may
have taken its time to get its act together, but when it did shot like a
rocket. And that’s fair enough, if the pattern does repeat anyone buying today
will look much smarter than me. However, let’s recall that the move in gold in
the first six months of 2016 was sharper than the one we’ve seen so far today,
from U$1,085/oz to U$1,355/oz (feel free to argue the toss about intraday reads,
I’m going with the London PM fix data), which is give-or-take +25%. In the same
time period, silver moved from U$13.80/oz to U$20.30/oz, roughly 47%. Yes,
that’s big beta to gold and probably why silver’s speculative attraction is
getting column inches, but we need to compare it to the current move in gold,
which can be spotted in other prices but I’m going to go with the global
general U$1,300/oz to U$1,400/oz, a 7.7% improvement. Even if you pimp the
bottom and top prices of the current gold move, it’s difficult to get over 10%
and that’s nowhere near the power of the turn we saw in early 2016…not yet at
least.

Yes, silver is now more tempting as a
speculative opportunity but that’s what it is, no more and no less (and I trust
you hold gold bullion for different reasons than mere speculation). The GSR is
very high at 93X, but the same people telling you it cannot go any higher are
the ones in March and April telling you that 85X was the top as well (and let
us be crystal clear about this, I was one of those and even if I allowed myself
time for the turn to happen and claim some mitigation, I was wrong). Therefore
and for the time being, I will stick with (name removed) as my sole
direct silver exposure and stick with mostly gold until there is a definite
change in the GSR trend. It is not our friend and fortunes have been lost by
people watching black coming up eight times in a row on a roulette wheel and
assuming the odds were 9/1 in their favour on the next spin (88.9%). No, sorry,
they were 48.64% that you’d win and 51.36% that you’d lose, the same as always.
Predicting nine trading days in a row is very different from watching eight and
predicting one.

However, both you and I should be ready with our
best trade ideas if silver does make that turn. At the very top of the GSR we
get a sharp waterfall drop that breaks through trends (note the 50dma and
200dma lines on the above chart, they’ll do as a start) and when that happens,
the silver stocks will blast off before you can get on the cheapest prices
(better put, “before I can get on the cheapest prices”). However, that should
not deter a new long position in silver as this chart featuring a few silver
names (from the top of my head, no cute cherrypicking on display) helps to
illustrate.

Bottom line: I will not try to catch this
falling silver ratio knife, but I am ready with trade ideas if the turn
materializes. Until then, gold is preferred at The IKN Weekly (except XXX).


Leave a Reply