Trey Reik has recently moved house from Sprott to Bristol Group and is doing fine there as well, for what it’s worth. He’s still one of the sharpest brains in the gold sphere and his grasp on the interaction between gold and the US market is second to none. Anyway, he’s let me paste out the whole of his July 2020 letter to clients, which went out just a few days ago. Enjoy:
Bristol
Gold Group
July 2020
Gold Group
July 2020
In
our early-July report, we shared perspective on daunting implications for U.S. capital
markets of recent Fed liquidity facilities.
We have taken issue with the Fed’s gross manipulation of asset prices to
the benefit of investment banks, sophisticated investment vehicles and market
speculators. Blow-off Q2 earnings at
Wall Street banks only served to prosecute our indictment. We believe the Covid pandemic provided the
perfect opportunity for the Fed finally to address suffocating U.S. debt
levels—by simply letting impaired credits and zombie enterprises fail and by
beginning to rationalize malinvestment fostered by a decade of QE and
ZIRP. Instead, the Fed flooded U.S. capital
markets with an absurd amount of artificial liquidity which has (once
again) suspended rational price discovery and further distanced the
dysfunctional U.S.
economy from any semblance of free markets.
our early-July report, we shared perspective on daunting implications for U.S. capital
markets of recent Fed liquidity facilities.
We have taken issue with the Fed’s gross manipulation of asset prices to
the benefit of investment banks, sophisticated investment vehicles and market
speculators. Blow-off Q2 earnings at
Wall Street banks only served to prosecute our indictment. We believe the Covid pandemic provided the
perfect opportunity for the Fed finally to address suffocating U.S. debt
levels—by simply letting impaired credits and zombie enterprises fail and by
beginning to rationalize malinvestment fostered by a decade of QE and
ZIRP. Instead, the Fed flooded U.S. capital
markets with an absurd amount of artificial liquidity which has (once
again) suspended rational price discovery and further distanced the
dysfunctional U.S.
economy from any semblance of free markets.
Fiscal Cliff
In
this report, we shift our attention to the fiscal side of U.S. Covid response. In the case of federal fiscal programs, it is
fair to say that at least the intentions of Congress and Treasury
have been more honorable than those of their Fed counterparts. Right or wrong, our nation’s broad imposition
of lockdowns actively deprived tens-of-millions of Americans of their ability
to earn a paycheck. Worse still,
government lockdowns inflicted the sharpest economic pain on those most
vulnerable to loss of income. By common
account, some 40% of Americans earning less than $40,000 lost their jobs during
April and May.
this report, we shift our attention to the fiscal side of U.S. Covid response. In the case of federal fiscal programs, it is
fair to say that at least the intentions of Congress and Treasury
have been more honorable than those of their Fed counterparts. Right or wrong, our nation’s broad imposition
of lockdowns actively deprived tens-of-millions of Americans of their ability
to earn a paycheck. Worse still,
government lockdowns inflicted the sharpest economic pain on those most
vulnerable to loss of income. By common
account, some 40% of Americans earning less than $40,000 lost their jobs during
April and May.
On
March 23, the U.S. Census Bureau launched the Household Pulse Survey, a comprehensive
effort to quantify nationwide impacts of Covid-19 on employment, food
availability, medical care, housing solvency and educational experience. In its 10th week of reporting
(7/7/20), the survey estimated https://www.census.gov/data-tools/demo/hhp/#/table?measures=HIR
that
49.9% of American households had lost employment income since
3/13/20; 34.9% of households expected additional lost income
during the next month; 40.1% of households had delayed medical
care in the prior four weeks; and 25.3% of adults (or
45,373,346 individuals) had either missed their household’s prior
month rent payment or held “slight or no confidence that their household could
pay the next month’s rent or mortgage payment on time.” Unbelievably, the percentage of American
households with children in private or public school where “classes were taught
in a distance learning format or changed in some other way” totaled a
mind-numbing 99.2%.
March 23, the U.S. Census Bureau launched the Household Pulse Survey, a comprehensive
effort to quantify nationwide impacts of Covid-19 on employment, food
availability, medical care, housing solvency and educational experience. In its 10th week of reporting
(7/7/20), the survey estimated https://www.census.gov/data-tools/demo/hhp/#/table?measures=HIR
that
49.9% of American households had lost employment income since
3/13/20; 34.9% of households expected additional lost income
during the next month; 40.1% of households had delayed medical
care in the prior four weeks; and 25.3% of adults (or
45,373,346 individuals) had either missed their household’s prior
month rent payment or held “slight or no confidence that their household could
pay the next month’s rent or mortgage payment on time.” Unbelievably, the percentage of American
households with children in private or public school where “classes were taught
in a distance learning format or changed in some other way” totaled a
mind-numbing 99.2%.
Unfortunately,
the well-intentioned nature of U.S.
fiscal policy in no way diminishes its catastrophic impact on already shaky U.S. finances. As recently as this past March, we were
fretting about a trailing 12-month federal budget deficit exceeding $1 trillion
for the first time since the GFC. Now,
the Q2 2020 deficit alone measured $2.0 trillion (including June’s all-time
monthly record $864 billion—a 102-fold increase over June 2019’s $8.5
billion), vaulting the trailing 12-month deficit to $2.982 trillion. Current CBO estimates project a fiscal 2020
(September) federal deficit of $3.7 trillion. To lend some perspective to
runaway Treasury borrowing, as shown in Figure 1, on the following page, after
exceeding net tax receipts for the first time in history this past May,
trailing 12-month Treasury issuance ($4.347 trillion) absolutely towered
above 12-month tax receipts ($3.113
trillion) in the period ended June.
the well-intentioned nature of U.S.
fiscal policy in no way diminishes its catastrophic impact on already shaky U.S. finances. As recently as this past March, we were
fretting about a trailing 12-month federal budget deficit exceeding $1 trillion
for the first time since the GFC. Now,
the Q2 2020 deficit alone measured $2.0 trillion (including June’s all-time
monthly record $864 billion—a 102-fold increase over June 2019’s $8.5
billion), vaulting the trailing 12-month deficit to $2.982 trillion. Current CBO estimates project a fiscal 2020
(September) federal deficit of $3.7 trillion. To lend some perspective to
runaway Treasury borrowing, as shown in Figure 1, on the following page, after
exceeding net tax receipts for the first time in history this past May,
trailing 12-month Treasury issuance ($4.347 trillion) absolutely towered
above 12-month tax receipts ($3.113
trillion) in the period ended June.
Figure 1: Net Tax
Receipts vs. U.S. Treasury
Issuance [12-month sum] (2006-June 2020) [Meridian
Macro]
Receipts vs. U.S. Treasury
Issuance [12-month sum] (2006-June 2020) [Meridian
Macro]
As
demonstrated in Figure 2, below, the rough mix of $1 trillion-worth of stimulus
checks and Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) loans has delayed for a few months
the inevitable reckoning of post-Covid employment realities. In quick succession, the federal ban on
eviction of (nonpaying) renters expired on 7/24; the $600 supplemental federal unemployment
insurance program expires on 7/31; and the PPP expires on 8/8. The bid/offer spread on the next round of
federal stimulus currently stands at $1-to-$3 trillion. Trillion! White House economic adviser Larry Kudlow has
even floated the concept of a “back to work bonus” to somehow encourage
unemployed workers back into the workforce.
How and when will fiscal safety nets stop? How will they ever be paid back?
demonstrated in Figure 2, below, the rough mix of $1 trillion-worth of stimulus
checks and Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) loans has delayed for a few months
the inevitable reckoning of post-Covid employment realities. In quick succession, the federal ban on
eviction of (nonpaying) renters expired on 7/24; the $600 supplemental federal unemployment
insurance program expires on 7/31; and the PPP expires on 8/8. The bid/offer spread on the next round of
federal stimulus currently stands at $1-to-$3 trillion. Trillion! White House economic adviser Larry Kudlow has
even floated the concept of a “back to work bonus” to somehow encourage
unemployed workers back into the workforce.
How and when will fiscal safety nets stop? How will they ever be paid back?
Figure 2: Weekly Disbursements of Unemployment
Insurance, Stimulus Checks and Paycheck Protection Program Loans
(3/6/20-7/10/20) [U.S. Treasury, U.S.
Census, Small Business Administration Evercore ISI]
Insurance, Stimulus Checks and Paycheck Protection Program Loans
(3/6/20-7/10/20) [U.S. Treasury, U.S.
Census, Small Business Administration Evercore ISI]
Traditional
inefficiency of governmental spending has reached new heights of fraud and
folly in the Covid era. The Government
Accountability Office acknowledged that a legal barrier prevented Treasury and
the IRS from consulting federal death records in mailing April’s 159 million
stimulus checks (totaling $267 billion).
Consequently, 1.1 million checks totaling $1.4 billion were distributed
to deceased citizens.
inefficiency of governmental spending has reached new heights of fraud and
folly in the Covid era. The Government
Accountability Office acknowledged that a legal barrier prevented Treasury and
the IRS from consulting federal death records in mailing April’s 159 million
stimulus checks (totaling $267 billion).
Consequently, 1.1 million checks totaling $1.4 billion were distributed
to deceased citizens.
The
PPP program will long stand as the most random and capricious federal handout
in our nation’s history. Totaling some
$669 billion (yes, that’s two-thirds of $1 trillion), the primary goal of the
PPP was to help entrepreneurs retain payroll employees so businesses and
workers might “ride out” what was anticipated to be a relatively short Covid
downturn. PPP was all about keeping
businesses afloat and protecting jobs.
Through mid-July, roughly 4.9 million PPP loans had been processed,
totaling some $518 billion. While we
have chuckled at federal prosecutions related to Lamborghini purchases and
cryptocurrency trading with PPP proceeds, the single best example of the lunacy
of such a federal endeavor has been the fact that neither the PPP application
nor the Small Business Administration’s electronic system (used by lenders to
submit applications)included a simple input field for “jobs retained.” To us, that seems like an important box for
the government to have checked!
PPP program will long stand as the most random and capricious federal handout
in our nation’s history. Totaling some
$669 billion (yes, that’s two-thirds of $1 trillion), the primary goal of the
PPP was to help entrepreneurs retain payroll employees so businesses and
workers might “ride out” what was anticipated to be a relatively short Covid
downturn. PPP was all about keeping
businesses afloat and protecting jobs.
Through mid-July, roughly 4.9 million PPP loans had been processed,
totaling some $518 billion. While we
have chuckled at federal prosecutions related to Lamborghini purchases and
cryptocurrency trading with PPP proceeds, the single best example of the lunacy
of such a federal endeavor has been the fact that neither the PPP application
nor the Small Business Administration’s electronic system (used by lenders to
submit applications)included a simple input field for “jobs retained.” To us, that seems like an important box for
the government to have checked!
Of
course, these details hold limited significance in context of Treasury
Secretary Mnuchin’s recent trial balloon to forgive completely the
87% of PPP loans measuring less than $150,000.
As Secretary Mnuchin testified to the House Small Business Committee on
7/17/20, “We should consider forgiving all small loans, but would need fraud
protection.” Where is this money coming
from? What has it accomplished? When
will the U.S.
dollar begin to reflect eroding U.S.
creditworthiness?
course, these details hold limited significance in context of Treasury
Secretary Mnuchin’s recent trial balloon to forgive completely the
87% of PPP loans measuring less than $150,000.
As Secretary Mnuchin testified to the House Small Business Committee on
7/17/20, “We should consider forgiving all small loans, but would need fraud
protection.” Where is this money coming
from? What has it accomplished? When
will the U.S.
dollar begin to reflect eroding U.S.
creditworthiness?
As
shown in Figure 3, on the prior page, ever since the launch of QE3 in September
2012, the spot gold price has demonstrated tight (inverse) correlation to the
trailing 12-month federal budget deficit.
Through March 2020, every $350B delta in the budget deficit (in either
direction) had accompanied a $300 (inverse) delta in the gold price. Should correlations of the past eight years
hold vaguely true, the $1.944 trillion Q2 deficit blowout would project to a
$3,200 gold price in short order.
Further, the CBO’s 4/24/20
estimate for a fiscal (Sept) 2020 deficit of $3.7 trillion projects a spot gold
price in the vicinity of $3,860 by year-end 2020. Even discounting this implied correlation by
50% (under the assumption pandemic conditions and related fiscal response are
merely temporary phenomena) the CBO’s 2020 deficit estimate would still project
a year-end 2020 gold price of $2,700.
shown in Figure 3, on the prior page, ever since the launch of QE3 in September
2012, the spot gold price has demonstrated tight (inverse) correlation to the
trailing 12-month federal budget deficit.
Through March 2020, every $350B delta in the budget deficit (in either
direction) had accompanied a $300 (inverse) delta in the gold price. Should correlations of the past eight years
hold vaguely true, the $1.944 trillion Q2 deficit blowout would project to a
$3,200 gold price in short order.
Further, the CBO’s 4/24/20
estimate for a fiscal (Sept) 2020 deficit of $3.7 trillion projects a spot gold
price in the vicinity of $3,860 by year-end 2020. Even discounting this implied correlation by
50% (under the assumption pandemic conditions and related fiscal response are
merely temporary phenomena) the CBO’s 2020 deficit estimate would still project
a year-end 2020 gold price of $2,700.
Stay
tuned and enjoy the final weeks of summer!
tuned and enjoy the final weeks of summer!
Sincerely,
Trey
Reik
Reik
Managing
Member
Member
Bristol
Gold Group LLC
Gold Group LLC
(508)
775 7056
775 7056


