That’s obvious. If you guys up there did, Peru stocks would have sold off a lot more than they have so far.

With the emphasis on “so far”. And this isn’t just about mining stocks, we already know its sector anal ysts couldn’t spot a political risk red flag if it were waved in front of their eyes by a seven foot Spetznatz veteran. No folks, there’s a reason IKN chooses the Peru broad market index tracker ETF (EPU) and compares to that of Chile (ECH) (as well as the SPX for context), this time the ignorance is a broad church and it’s not just a few million in bad bets on explorecos. Some weakness yes, but you ain’t seen nothing yet.
Markets haven’t sold off yet because for some reason, up there you guys think Keiko will waltz it and the Commie yokel doesn’t stand a chance. Sadly, this desk begs to differ and predicts Peru will elect Pedro Castillo, an out-and-out unalloyed Communist, as its next President. For the second round, there will be three main dynamics in play:
- With 20/20 hindsight (and apologies for using it), it’s clear last Sunday’s vote was Peru’s revenge on its corrupt and vomit-inducing political class. It was Peru’s version of the Burn TWF Thing Down, joining the list of countries that have turned round, looked its capital city in the eye and lifted its middle finger. Each country has found its own way and Peru’s is also more complicated than a single sentence, but in essence its neglected provinces joined the list of people who got revenge by voting for “one of them”, a fellow provinciano. However, they are also antagonizing with his extreme left wing ticket, a double nightmare for the ruling class. That provincial/poor-urban tendency to want to stick it to Peru’s ruling class and BTWFTD isn’t going to die down in the next eight weeks and in all likelihood, will grow.
- Up your way and even still in Lima, Pedro Castillo is being made out as a high school teacher in a backwater town with radical politics who got militant in his party and then got lucky. Errr, no. He may not be the best orator and the local garb and funny hats might make him look “quaint” but scrub the spin from your brain right now, this a smart and canny political operator who knows his way around the Peruvian left wing. What’s more, he has a clear path to victory via the playbook written years ago by Ollanta Humala; Get to the run-off on an extreme agenda, call for consensus, get together with the losing candidates, create a brand new policy book to offer the country in round two based on consensus of centre/left parties (who will quickly fall into line, power whores they all are). Suddenly the Communist wolf is dressed in sheep’s clothing and what’s more, the intellectually corrupt and power hungry Peru left wing will go for it, too. As bad as the right, they want all the slush they’re offered so when it comes to reaching consensus on a broad front for Round Two, they’ll justify with “It’s best to control him from within”. Instead, these whores will open the door to a dangerous man with even more dangerous friends, the type that close down Congress at the first opportunity and not the last. Be clear, the Left will enable Castillo and turn him into a serious candidate.
- The North underestimates the Keiko Fujimori anti-vote. Round One wasn’t a logical result, it needed a sequence of bizarre circumstances for Keiko to reach the second round, one of them was a vote that was split into so many fractions that her strong anti-vote ceiling didn’t come into play. Frankly that was my mistake in the IKN Weekly pre-election anal yses as well, I thought the hard 70% to 75% of people polled who say they will never, ever vote for Keiko Fujimori under any circumstances (due to the manifold scandals around her and the family) would be enough to keep her out of the run-off. Instead, she picked up just enough extra voters (5%?) in highly fractured field on the back of a hard-line populist campaign to add to her solid 8% base and sneaked in the back door. Good politicking to be sure, but be clear her hard ceiling has not disappeared and it would take a lot of Peruvians going back on the “Never, under any circumstances” position for Keiko Fujimori to garner enough votes to win. Not impossible of course, but it’s way more difficult than the North currently imagines. What’s certainly wrong is the North’s blithe assumption that Castillo loses, in fact he goes into round two as favourite no matter what the polls might say, as this seven-headed nightmare of election will be decided in the provinces, not in Lima
The house call in IKN613 seven weeks ago to sell Peru has already saved subscribers from significant losses, today’s follow-up goes out on the free blog and it’s still not good news. Sell Peru now and do not go back, the country is heading for political disaster and what’s more, the mining industry is going to be at the very centre of the storm. You have been warned.
maybe he’ll see the presidency as his vehicle to instant riches, like every other a-hole elected, and forget all about his pre-electorate agenda, like Humala did?
Hey Mark, appreciate the insight. How does the congress fit in here? Castillo or Fujimori. can any of them do anything harmful or does the current congress have a check on what they could actually do. Cheers
That made me laugh, thanks.