IKN

Take physic, pomp

Rio2: Chinchilla mailbag

Reader and mailpal “R” sent over his tongue in his cheek yesterday evening…

Dear Sir,
If disturbing chinchillas is a problem, why not employ local naturalists to raise and breed then release the lovely creatures back into the wilderness? The cost to sponsor such an endeavor would be minuscule. As crazy as it sounds… call it the “Fenix Project Chinchilla Repopulation Plan”.
Could it be that difficult to convince the powers that be to buy in? Programs like this saved the American Bald Eagle and countless other marginalized species.
Thoughts?
Sincerely, R.
PS. It’s cocktail hour, but a stiff Cubano cafe could give the same results.

…and got this reply.

R,
I get it and I get you (and I have a cafe americano on the go, as luck would have it), but you’re going to get a (semi) serious answer because you’re not as far off as you might think.
Rio2 is waiting patiently for the publication of the RCA (resolucion de calificación ambiental), which is basically the EIA decision document. At that point we’ll know the official reason as to why its permit was denied and that’s not a small thing, because while we know the decision was ideologically biased they need to adhere to the letter of the law in Chile. Therefore they need to state for the record what Rio2’s deficiency was in its permit application. At that point Rio2 can offer its mitigation and yes indeed, they could as part of that offer to breed chinchillas and populate half the Southern Andean cordillera if the country so desires (pardon the pun but being rodents, give them the right conditions and they’ll breed like rabbits). Or they could set aside an exclusion area. Or run a Sponsor A Chinchilla Club for a local school. A thousand ideas, but the important part is about the law because, unless it gets changed (and it won’t), once Rio2 complies with the demands of an environmental permitting body in Chile that body is obliged to award the permit.
Of course we live in the real world and obviously this doesn’t preclude the people set against awarding permits to mining companies finding another reason/excuse, or dragging heels, or using some or other political mechanism to keep the nasty mining men away from their pristine environment. However, on the one hand the game becomes far more obvious and for another, the clock is ultimately in favour of the project owner. So while I agree this is a royal pain in the butt for shareholders, Rio2 at Fenix is far from dead and time will heal its wounds.

The bottom line: We await the RCA, then Rio2 ramps up its mitigation program (and along the way, comes to some kind of new agreement with Wheaton). The appeals process is a clearly defined path and while that’s on, the company will be able to enact all sorts of monitoring and environmental protection initiatives for what is, ultimately, a fixable problem. As stated previously, the SEA people at head office decided to refuse the permit and then went about finding a way of doing so, this was all they found (and you may recall, they green-lighted all the things that might normally cause red flags in Chile such as its “truck the water” program, dust/noise/etc contaminations, the strict laws that apply to all mining operations about 3,000masl in Chile and a long list of et ceteras.

And for what it’s worth, I know of a criadero de chinchilla in the Peru highlands. They breed them for their pelts, which apparently have a strong market in China and Mongolia (of all places).

Best, m

And for those who’ve never tried it, add sugar to your demitasse first then a few drops of your espresso. Then stir thoroughly to form a creamy mix and when done, add the rest of the espresso shot. The result in an espresso with a sweetish froth on top, A Cafe Cubano.

P.S. The RCA has just been released; 319 pages of wholesome environmental fun, out today and my idea of nighttime reading.

5 Comments

    Rio2 are aware of the problems Goldfields had at salares Norte the SEA requested the capturing and relocation of chinchilla knowing the little rodent weak hearts can be stopped by a loud fart.So when two died SEA regulators took the it’s your problem not ours shut everything down.Hopefully Rio2 will learn from this and employ a chinchilla whisperer who will have a secret stash of Chinchilla to hand to replace any that may take the appearance of a very restful rodent.OJ 😉

    Would be very interested to hear your insights based on the environmental rejection news today for AAL and also the positive environmental development for LA.V yesterday. Perhaps, items you could address in your next blog posting?

      6 RCAs out of 6 now rejected by Chile since March, and an exploreco has to jump through hoops just to get a limited drill program out of purgatory. LA.v has more problems than RIO.v, frankly.

    any new findings in the 300 rca pages? 😉
    is it still the water trucking issue after all?

Leave a Reply