IKN

Take physic, pomp

Ecuador: The problem with the current agreement with indigenous locals (from IKN688)

This made last weekend’s edition of The IKN Weekly and covers the declarations made by the ex-Vice Minister of Mining in Ecuador on the current state of play in the country’s sector and what we can expect when the current 90 day negotiation period between the government and the indigenous groups led by CONAIE expires.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Ecuador: The problem with the current agreement with indigenous locals

Fernando Benalcázar was Vice-Minister of Mines in previous administration to that of President Lasso, serving under President Lenín Moreno. Last week he gave this interview to Ecuador national daily La Hora (20) and in part of it, gave the following analysis (translated) to the agreement reached as part of the deal between Lasso and the protesting groups (led by indigenous umbrella group CONAIE) regarding mining.

Benalcázar gets it right and explains the problem regarding the fall of the so-called Mining Law (Decree 151), the draft agreement between the government and protesters (Decree 468) pertaining to the non-development of “Ancestral Territories” and the current 90 day workshop period going on between interested parties:

Reporter: Why are the plans for mining and oil&gas companies affected?

Fernando Benalcázar: (The deal) has opened the potential for prohibition of the extractive industries in “Ancestral Territories and Archaeological Zones”. Where in the Constitution or laws of Ecuador is the definition of an “Ancestral Territory”? The answer is nowhere. It’s amazing to think that in 90 days somebody would be able to resolve this issue, even if they worked 24/7 with multi-disciplinary teams of sociologists, social scientists and engineers I cannot see how they can get to define what is an Ancestral Territory. We have no idea what criteria they will prefer, how they’ll arrive at a definition or what course they’ll take. It could come from the indigenous groups’ side (and) I’ve heard declarations made that practically all territories are ancestral in nature. This won’t be resolved in 90 days, just the implementation could take two years. Another point of conflict is to promote the idea that as an exception to the rule, extractive activities (mining/hydrocarbons) could take place if agreements already exist previous to Decree 468 as in those cases, they will respect the decisions of local communities. This is a Pandora’s Box and would violate the Constitution, in which the right of prior consultancy is established but even if the majority of the population is against (any given project), the final decision rests with the government.”

Reporter: Can the situation be solved?

Fernando Benalcázar: There are now two options and Decree 468 makes this clear: Either everything is suspended until a definition is agreed upon, or we continue and the dialogue breaks down. It wouldn’t be a surprise to see another protest and strike action a month after the 90 day period is over.

Reporter: What’s happening with (mining and hydrocarbons) investments?

Fernando Benalcázar: They (the government) must be crazy of they think people will invest without knowing what will happen in 90 days’ time. I wouldn’t put a single dollar into Ecuador under the present circumstances.

1 Comment

    90-days to ID all Heritage Zones? It’s already in the GIS! Reading this you get a sense of how difficult it is to do business in EC. It’s like trying to work with a wet wool blanket over your head. SNAFU wherever you turn. If you don’t have a sufficient local constituency backing your project, you don’t have a project. To gain local acceptance normally takes years of working with the community. Cash/facts don’t = win. Want a slam dunk project? Location, location, location.

Leave a Reply