“And does history repeat itself, the first time as tragedy, the second time as farce? No, that’s too grand, too considered a process. History just burps, and we taste again that raw-onion sandwich it swallowed centuries ago.”
Julian Barnes, A History of the World in 10½ Chapters
After chewing over the 3q22 numbers filed by “New Sandstorm” (SAND) (SSL.to) this morning, now its Hod-Maden-Out-Nomad-In corporate move is done and dusted, the only strong conclusion drawn by this desk is that its share price underperformance is set to continue through 2023. What happens after that is another story and you never know, one of these days the breathless, sycophantic lionizations of Nolan Watson and his team currently doing the rounds may bear some fruit at some stage but, for the time being at least, no matter how well the company does financially in the next few quarters it’s going to be a drag of a stock for retail to hold.
The reason is simple, SAND is planning to dilute the upside away from you. How do we know? Check its long-term track record. These quarterly charts for assets, liabilities and share count go back to the start of 2015 and show the pathology of the people running this company. Though near-term assets were thin, they’ve kept enough liquidity to keep going through the shape-shifting period so cash isn’t an issue. And to cut them a little more slack, we can argue over whether the new fixed asset total is worth what SAND says it’s worth another day…

…but what we do know is that liability column for 3q22 is real, because it’s nearly all in hard dollars:

That debt now needs servicing, which will drag on the bottom line for as long as it remains high. With that, we arrive at the moment when this humble corner of cyberspace explains why SAND is destined to lag FNV, WPM, RGLD and whatever other royaltyco you use as a benchmark, also why we’ve gone so far back in time on these charts. Though previously for more modest totals, SAND has occasionally used temporary debt (normally its revolver) to fund asset purchases and as you can make out, they’ve always been keen on paying debt down. Returning to the 3q22 numbers and…Ka-Chow…a welter burden of U$571.948m on its books as at end 3q22, with U$31.549m of that in the currents and U$540.399m in the long-terms. And true to form, SAND took immediate steps to lower its debt load as we read in this morning’s accompanying NR…
“Subsequent to quarter’s end, the Company completed an equity financing for aggregate gross proceeds of $92.1 million on October 4, 2022. Upon closing of the financing, the majority of net proceeds were used to reduce amounts drawn under the Company’s revolving credit facility.“
…which is no surprise, considering its track record. However, are you seriously suggesting the company is planning to leave all that serviceable debt on its books and pay it down at a rate of just $20m or $30m a quarter from its cash flow? An example of the snail’s pace that would imply is in the 1q23est column for liabilities, in which we assume the company applies as much of its free cash flow to reducing the revolver as possible but even then, it’d take literally years to get it back to a comfortable level, let alone back to zero. No way they’ve going to wait that long, especially when you consider…

…this is the company that has also has a long track record of playing games with its share count, using them to pay for purchases, selling shares to witless instos and funds that get romanced into deals over expense account lunches without ever looking behind the curtain, or using the cover of NCIB buybacks to allow its insiders to cash out deeply ITM incentive options without the total moving up much. So anyone who thinks the recent placement was a one-off is in for a surprise, it’s a confident bet that SAND is planning to run a couple more placements in order to drop that debt pile as quickly as possible and set itself in shape for the next wheeler deal. Great for the executives, great for the acquisition targets, great for the brokerages and great for the lawyers behind the scene. Great for everyone in fact…except current shareholders.
Bottom line: SAND underperforms in 2023, so get used to the idea.