IKN

Take physic, pomp

Aclara Resources (ARA.to) and community relations

The best bit of the Aclara Resources (ARA.to) “2022 Review and 2023 Outlook” NR today is the bit where they gloss over its CSR:

“The dialogue with the local community has been a top priority for us and we are pleased to have opened ourselves to them and have been receiving feedback as to how to improve. We are very pleased to be in Chile and are committed to a project which we believe will be beneficial to Penco and to the environment.“

That compares with the last time its CSR results were mentioned in any great depth by the company, in its 1q22 MD&A:

“The dialogue with communities has been supported by monthly meetings (known locally as “juntas de participación”), that were complemented by site visits to the project area, and specific meetings in relevant neighbourhoods. As of March 31, 2022, a total of 17 meetings were held with different community development of the Penco Module. On February 27, 2022, the Municipality of Penco held a non-binding consultation to poll local residents on the development of the Penco Module. Of the 42,186 eligible registered voters of Penco and Lirquen, 7,548 people turned out to vote (representing a turnout of 17.89%) in the said consultation of which 7,474 people voted against the installation of the proposed project. As a response to this development, the Company will be undertaking a local community outreach program during 2022.“

It was around the time of that referendum vote that ARA decided to withdraw its environmental permit application in order to (and we quote) “…strengthen environmental, technical and social aspects of the Penco Module project.” The Ottotrans of that is “we knew it would be rejected, so we stopped the process” and in practice, it’s “strengthening” turned out to be the wholesale firing of the old CSR outreach crew and the hiring of a new group. However, things are still going badly for ARA in and around Penco and the locals haven’t fallen for the new approach. Local newspaper Diario de Concepcion ran its “Announcement of company that insists on realizing “Rare Earths” project in Penco is rejected out of hand” report on October 30th, then just last month this report from Chile’s news magazine “Resumen’ on the new outreach strategy by Aclara has another snappy title: “We are faced with a blatant disinformation campaign in Penco”: Rare Earths mining company Aclara criticized for questionable diffusion of propaganda“. Both those reports give a view that’s rather different from the image ARA is trying to sell to you gringo suckers up there and both offer ample evidence of a depth of feeling against this project. It’s so bad that ARA is using the term “rare earths harvesting” in its literature, anything to avoid The M Word with the locals. To quote one Leonardo Jara, head of one of the associations that have sprung up to defend the locality against this project:

“If they want to talk about responsibility, transparency and truth, they should submit their Environmental Impact Study and adhere to the actions that the EIA process specifies, such as citizen participation meetings and consultancies….if they want to run propaganda, they can’t at the same time invalidate the citizens who have already said, more than 99.9%, that they don’t want this mine.”

He has a point.

Leave a Reply