The intro from last Sunday explained why there are other options for gold than simple “to the moon” or “crash coming now!” Instead, this desk believes $2k or so may turn out to be sticky and have been calling it so for the last four weeks. So far at least, reality fits the theory.
Gold: I want to believe
I do get it, it’s not that I’m trying to ignore the obvious:
- Gold is The Fear Trade.
- If the Fed pauses too early, inflation takes off again. Real interest rates climb and as fear grips the market, gold catches its bid.
- If the Fed continues to hike rates, the tightening rates scenario causes more financial sector failures as seen recently with US regional banks (SVB etc). Fear grips the market and gold catches its bid.
- Therefore, if the Fed raises rates, gold goes up and if the Fed pauses (or dare we even mention, cuts bps rates) gold goes up.
- Because gold is The Fear Trade.
It may turn out to be true in the longer-term, too. However, there are a couple of things stopping me from believing in the latest version of “You Cannot Lose With Gold” thesis:
- We’ve been here before. Hardly the first time the pro-gold community can only see upside in the monetary metal
- Bonds will still yield. The Fear Trade will need a large dose of fear to work, but what if the Fear doesn’t materialize? What happens if our financial markets manage to negotiate an admittedly sticky period without its creaking edifice crashing into a million pieces? As one example, by simple trial and error the Fed has now recognized a weak link in the shape of US regional banks, so what’s to stop them from keeping the liquidity window open and making sure they don’t hit a cash crunch due to their collective decision to take on term bonds positions? Yes for sure it would be called “QE that isn’t QE” by its detractors, they may even call it “cheating”, but there’s no law against the strategy. And as long as the world keeps its confidence in the US banking system, its currency and therefore its interest-yielding paper will remain the primary safe haven during a stress-laden recessionary period.
- Black Swans are not easy bets. The current Fear Trade “Win-Win” thesis on gold is essentially a very large tail risk bet, one that covers the US Dollar as much as anything else. You are betting on things going wrong and that’s a reasonable way of building a hedge position, not a primary investment. It all harks back to the basic reason to buy and own gold; it’s the insurance policy, it’s your baseline and if it’s the top performing asset in a balanced portfolio, it signals that other things are going wrong…bigtime. Or as this desk has stated on too many occasions already, gold doesn’t make you rich, it’s there to stop you from becoming poor.
Predicting higher prices for gold in the time frame of your choice has suddenly become a popular and alluring call. It’s what the audience wants to hear, it makes you friends and hey, even if it goes wrong you can always blame “them” or “the banksters” or “the crooked system”. After all, there’s more than just one no lose proposition in the precious metals world at the moment. This desk’s scepticism remains intact and we’ll continue with sincere opinions be they right or wrong, popular or unpopular. Now for the rest of today’s intro, in which we expand on the reasons why I’m still good about my “gold floating around $2,000/oz” call of three weeks ago for the time being.