By request on the open blog, this note from IKN725 last weekend is an update on the increasingly precarious situation of the President of Ecuador, Guillermo Lasso. It’s of direct interest to the mining industry as if Lasso falls, whoever replaces him will not be as open towards the capitalist world of mining (though China might be happy…that’s another story). Take that to the bank but in the meantime, get up to speed on what Lasso is facing in April and May 2023.
The trials of Guillermo Lasso
After taking a week off from covering the whacko world of Ecuador politics as affects President Guillermo Lasso (and therefore its mining industry), we need to get up to speed because the country seems to be reaching an inflection point and the President’s hold on power is looking even more tenuous than before. To begin, let’s get up to speed via this report (19) published last Monday from a news site I’d never heard of previously, The World (dot org). This is succinct, accurate and covers all the basics in a more eloquent way than I could achieve:
He’s accused of allowing embezzlement to continue under his watch in Ecuador’s oil shipping company, Flopec. According to evidence, he was advised of the corruption even before taking the presidency, but did not move to stop it. This is one of several accusations against him, including bribery and abuse of power.
The Ecuadorian outlet La Posta has recently accused Lasso’s brother-in-law and business associate Danilo Carrera of being at the center of a web of corruption, including involvement in false energy contracts and a cash-for-appointment bribery scheme.
However, the embezzlement charge was the only one approved by the Constitutional Court to be considered for the National Assembly’s impeachment proceedings.
“I am innocent,” Lasso said during a televised address to the nation the day after the court ruling. “In my personal, professional and public life, I have always acted with clear intention. And that’s why I denounce this impeachment trial, which smells very bad.”
If the case gets to Congress and the National Assembly, they will need 92 votes of the total 137 in order to pass the impeachment ruling and oust Lasso from the Presidency. According to the head of the special impeachment commission, the blocs ready to vote him out count up to at least 96 votes and potentially 104 votes and that means the only thing between Lasso and the ouster is the current stage of the process, the hearing at the Constitutional Court (CC).
That began on Monday and the day before, last Sunday evening, President Lasso gave a TV interview on national TV (Ecuavisa’s Sunday evening politics show) to vigorously defend his position, claim innocence on all charges and also confirm he would appear before the CC to defend his position because (translated), “…it is my obligation to show my face to the population.” In the same interview he also said he wouldn’t use the so-called “Muerte Cruzada” mechanism to avoid the process. We’ve translated this previously on these pages as “Crossfire Death” and as explained in IKN722 three weeks ago, the Constitution… “…gives the President to right to dissolve Congress and rule by decree for six months, as long as the President then also resigns by a fixed date and new national elections are held within 12 months.” If he triggers “Muerte Cruzada” he’d therefore avoid the final part of the impeachment process, that of the Congressional debate and vote, so there’s plenty of speculation in Ecuador on the subject and here’s what Lasso said on Sunday (translated):
“I couldn’t enact the “muerte cruzada” and leave doubts about what truly might have happened in this political trial because I am a democrat, because I expose my chest to the bullets in all aspects of my life.”
All rather florid. However, his position may “adjust” if things don’t go as well as he imagines at the CC and with that in mind, here’s the slated timeline (20):
- Last Monday, the clock starter ticking on the 10 working day process at the CC, with lawyers for both sides presenting their cases.
- As from end this week, the CC has ten working days to evaluate the evidence presented, That’s another two weeks (plus a couple of days due to the Easter week public holidays).
- After that, the CC has a final ten day period to write its report, which gives us an approximate time limit of the first week in May.
- If CC report recommends that the impeachment process continues, the case is then handed to the President of the National Assembly (Congress) who has a maximum of three days to publish the report and then a maximum of seven calendar days to call the Congress debate/vote.
As you may appreciate, one thing to say “no muerte cruzada” for the TV while the case is still in front of the CC, but quite another if it gets past this stage and the CC then hands it on to the National Assembly (i.e. Congress) for what would almost certainly be the vote that ousts Lasso. He’d have plenty of time to hit that big red button, dissolve Congress and run the country by executive decree. Theoretically at least, because the protests in light of such a move would be immediate and big, with Ecuador spiralling into a chaos that would put last year’s marches to shame. Meanwhile, Lasso’s enemies are now circling for the kill and on Sunday, he called the main players “The Triumvirate of Conspiracy” (he’s eloquent, I’ll give him that). They are 1) his most direct enemy Rafael Correa and his party. They were the big winners in the recent regional and municipal elections and Correa (or his dauphin) would be highly likely to become the next President were new elections called. Then 2) the indigenous umbrella group CONAIE and its leader, the increasingly powerful Leonidas Iza. It was CONAIE and Iza that ran last year’s protest marches and he/they would be front and centre if social protests began again. Finally we have 3) Jaime Nebot, the ex-mayor of Ecuador’s richest city Guayaquil and leader of his own right wing political party. Nebot was a supporter of Lasso’s but has turned against the President and has made plenty of public criticisms and attacks recently. He would have designs on capturing the right wing vote in any eventual presidential race (and has made no secret of his desire for the top job, although he’d have an uphill task against Correa and his party this time around). This “Triumvirate of Conspiracy” are not natural political bedfellows and only truly align when the subject is Lasso, but the highly anti-mining position taken by CONAIE is important under present circumstances because it’s one of the main issues that has weakened Lasso in the last 12 months and would almost certainly be one that the other two would want to respect in order to gain votes in an election. That, in a nutshell, is the current political power and leverage of CONAIE and the anti-miners in Ecuador today. CONAIE (or its formal political party Pachakutik) don’t have the national reach to win an election for their own candidate but they can play kingmaker and, knowing Correa, he’d happily make concessions to indigenous locals on the subject of hard rock mining in order to win the presidency (as long as current oil production weren’t affected, the major source of USD income).
And that’s where we stand today. There’s a lot riding on this court decision and even if they decide not to recommend Lasso for censure in Congress, it won’t be the end of the story by a long way. There are nuances and variants for sure, but your three basic scenarios as from around next month are:
- Lasso’s impeachment case is recommended to continue by the CC. The process goes to Congress, the debate and vote happens, he is almost certainly impeached and voted out of office.
- Lasso’s impeachment case is recommended to continue by the CC. Before the Congress debate starts Lasso invokes the called Muerte Cruzada/Crossfire Death mechanism and rules by decree for six months, with national presidential and congressional elections brought forward to this time next year
- Lasso’s impeachment case is NOT recommended to continue by the CC. This would spark immediate protests across the country in the style outlined last week, with a first set of national marches followed by a second and larger protest at some point, with enormous pressure put on Lasso to resign.
The only obvious win for Lasso would be the unlikely potential that he allows the process to go to congressional vote and wins out when the vote count for impeachment falls short of the 92 required. As things stand today, that’s highly unlikely and as such, Ecuador’s political risk looks set for a leg down in the weeks ahead. Further out, be clear that mining will be a hot button topic for any election process.