IKN

Take physic, pomp

When is a bought deal not a bought deal? (Part Two)

Back in October 2011 we looked at how Canada’s National Bank decided to re-write the rules on bought deals because….well, because it’s a bullying heads-I-win-tails you-lose bank, basically. Instead of honouring its commitment to a “bought deal” placement, it refused to play ball with Sulliden and take up $25m of the bought deal as arranged. In that post we defined the term bought deal so as it’s also useful today, here it is again:

A bought deal occurs when an underwriter, such as an investment bank or a syndicate, purchases securities from an issuer before a preliminary prospectus is filed. The investment bank (or underwriter) acts as principal rather than agent and thus actually “goes long” in the security. The bank negotiates a price with the issuer (usually at a discount to the current market price, if applicable).
The advantage of the bought deal from the issuer’s perspective is that they do not have to worry about financing risk (the risk that the financing can only be done at a discount too steep to market price.) This is in contrast to a fully marketed offering, where the underwriters have to “market” the offering to prospective buyers, only after which the price is set.
The advantages of the bought deal from the underwriter’s perspective include:

  1. Bought deals are usually priced at a larger discount to market than fully marketed deals, and thus may be easier to sell; and
  2. The issuer/client may only be willing to do a deal if it is bought (as it eliminates execution or market risk.)

The disadvantage of the bought deal from the underwriter’s perspective is that if it cannot sell the securities, it must hold them. This is usually the result of the market price falling below the issue price, which means the underwriter loses money. The underwriter also uses up its capital, which would probably otherwise be put to better use (given sell-side investment banks are not usually in the business of buying new issues of securities).

Ok, onwards. Last night (yes folks, it’s the late night NR syndrome again) we got this NR from Rio Novo (RN.to):

March 6, 2012 – 10:57:12 PM


TORONTO, ONTARIO–(Marketwire – March 6, 2012) –

NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION TO U.S. NEWS WIRE SERVICES OR DISSEMINATION IN THE UNITED STATES

Rio Novo Gold Inc. (TSX:RN)(TSX:RN.WT) (“Rio Novo” or the “Company”) wishes to announce that it has agreed to terminate the underwriting agreement with a syndicate of underwriters led by Canaccord Genuity Corp. and including Clarus Securities Inc., Dundee Securities Corporation, GMP Securities L.P., and UBS Securities Canada Inc. in respect of its previously announced $20,025,000 bought deal financing, and that the Company will not be proceeding with the offering at the present time.

In other words, yet another Canadian brokerage with no shame just pulls the plug on a deal that it decided it didn’t want to do anymore. It can do this because of the hermetic lockdown the brokerages have on this one-sided financing game in Canada. And the reason for the volte-face by The Can of Corn is that the offering was struck at 75c and these days RN.to trades at 55c.

In the October post, we finished of with the line “The time is ripe for alternative sources of financing for mining activities other than the rip-off Canadian houses. “. That timer gets riper still.

Leave a Reply