IKN

Take physic, pomp

Eurasian on Peru’s cabinet reshuffle

Out today.

PERU: Cabinet changes reinforce investor-friendly policy, but could increase protests
12 December 2011 02:25 PM EST

A recent cabinet reshuffle reflects President Ollanta Humala’s desire to have a tighter grip on the government, but is unlikely to yield any substantial shift in policy. If anything, it confirms Humala’s commitment to investor-friendly economic policies. The cabinet changes probably suggest that the government will take a harder line towards protests against mining projects. This means the government will seek to protect mining investments and will neither fuel nor politically use protests against the mining sector, as some feared. Still, taking a hard line could generate additional instability by further fueling protests. Humala could lose some political support from leftist groups, but this is unlikely to significantly affect his ability to govern.
President Ollanta Humala faced his first substantial political crisis with the unexpected resignation on 10 December of Prime Minister Salomon Lerner, one of his key advisors. Lerner’s resignation led to a significant cabinet reshuffle (over half of the cabinet was replaced). While Lerner’s departure seems to have been brewing for several weeks, the trigger appears to have been a disagreement over how to handle social protests, in particular his handling of the conflict over Newmont’s $4.8 billion Conga gold and copper project (Humala reportedly favored a tougher approach). Growing protests led the company to suspend the project and the government to declare a state of emergency on 5 December. It also seems Humala became frustrated with his a somewhat conflicted cabinet, whose differing views on key issues (such as mining) were generating the impression that the government lacked control over the country’s political situation. As such, Humala is probably seeking to gain more direct control of the government now that he has been in office for several months, and also have a more homogeneous cabinet with less dissenting views.

Lerner has been replaced by military-man Oscar Valdez Dancourt, who was interior minister. The cabinet reshuffle is unlikely to lead to a major shift in policy, and if anything will probably reinforce the current investor-friendly direction of economic policy. Economy Minister Luis Castilla will remain in his post, and Jorge Humberto Merino Tafur will be the new mining minister (he also comes from the industry). Other replacements include the ministries of agriculture, production, culture, environment, women issues, justice, interior, labor, and defense. These replacements leave the cabinet with a higher proportion of technocrats and a lower proportion of more leftist appointees (including Lerner, who was more of a leftist than many seem to remember), which if anything will reinforce the government’s market-friendly orientation.

Perhaps the main signal emanating from this cabinet shift is that it suggests that Humala will deal with protests against mining and other natural resources forcefully, and will seek to protect mining projects and investments. It shows, first, that Humala will not side, fuel or politically use protests against mining projects, as some had feared, and is willing to clash with groups that could put mining investment at risk. Clearly the Humala administration understands the importance of mining investment in terms of economic stability and, more importantly, as a source of fiscal revenue needed to fulfill the government’s ambitious social spending agenda, which will in turn determine his political success. As such, he is not willing to tolerate major risks to the investment pipeline.

The future of Newmont’s Conga project however, remains uncertain. Valdez said the government would seek an international evaluation of the project in order to reduce tension with local communities. The conflict will not necessarily be resolved, but it seems the government will throw its weight behind such an important mining project, increasing the likelihood that it moves forward, despite local opposition.

If the government does indeed take a hard line attitude towards protestors, it would generate the risk that this actually aggravates social tensions and thus causes increased, or more intense, instability. Widespread protests against mining companies have been one of the main risks affecting the mining sector in Peru. To a great extent they are a function of a weak political system that does not provide institutional mechanisms for channeling popular demands or concerns. A more repressive stance will do little to ease those problems. On the contrary, it may reinforce the sense that the government is on the side of mining companies and thus strengthen anti-mining groups. As such, we do see some risk that the government strategy could backfire.

The cabinet reshuffle has been criticized by leftists groups that believe either this is a move towards the right or a “militarization” of the cabinet (neither of which is true, in our view). Former president Alejandro Toledo also said he would not support the government anymore (apparently Humala did not offer him any cabinet posts), which could diminish Humala’s support in congress. Humala’s Gana Peru bloc has 47 (out of 130) seats in congress, while Toledo’s has 20. Still, none of this is likely to have a major impact on Humala’s ability to govern. Majorities in congress can be built given Peru’s weak party system, at least as long as the president remains popular and legislation is not particularly controversial. Thus, even though Humala could lose some support, we don’t see this as a threat to his ability to govern effectively.

Daniel Kerner
Analyst, Latin America

Leave a Reply