It’s been a couple of months since I’d quietly trudged through it myself* and decided not to comment around these parts (the debate was hot at the time, one extra small voice un-needed), but Weeks’ call on the tome today hit most of my main takeaways as well and gave me the feeling we’d read the same book (unlike many of the spleen-ridden reviews I’ve seen) so go have a look.
- Yes, this Piketty guy really isn’t that radical once you strip the r > g hype and polemic out.
- Yes, the economics community has had a rare old fit of pique about him. Probably jealousy. Idiots.
- Yes, the book is pitched at the layperson (though it does have the necessary academic rigour to pass muster among the ‘serious people’) and as such it’s not that surprising that it’s reached best-seller status (again pissing off the econ-crew to no small measure, e.g. Taleb’s ego-spiked envy was precious). But unlike the attitude in Ivory Towers of academia, surely that’s a good thing rather than a bad thing.
- Yes, a lot of the points being raised aren’t much more than fuel for ongoing debate. Piketty says this, Weeks gets this, so many others have not understood this.
For me, the only major point I’d liked to have seen from Weeks’ admittedly brief summary of the book is how Piketty points out the post WW1 to late 20th century period was an exception in economics terms, rather than the rule. R>G was around for centuries before and if now left unchecked we’ll return to that norm. For a brief period meritocracy ruled, but it’s a ~60 year anomaly in a period at least ten times that long (and perhaps much much longer). This was for me the biggest wake-up call from reading the book, that my idea of normal isn’t normal.
Anyway, go see the Greg Weeks post, it’s not that long and makes its points well.
PS: To answer a reader, I used the verb “trudged” to describe reading the book because of its length, not because it was boring. On the contrary, it was a genuinely interesting read (and my stars, that’s rare in economics/finance) and I’d recommend it to anyone. Good book, that Piketty book.
*fwiw on a pirated e-book copy, of which I strongly suspect Piketty would approve. Even if he doesn’t I don’t care.