IKN

Take physic, pomp

A reminder that earthquakes don’t kill people

Poor quality buildings kill people.
Last night in the Cusco region of Peru there was a 4.8mag tremor that hit just 8km underneath the small village of Paruro. Though a 4.8mag is relatively small, the combination of its shallow depth and the local houses being mostly made of poor quality adobe mud bricks with little in the way of foundations left a reported eight people dead, seven injured and around 45% of the village destroyed.
This is a topical example of a story that gets repeated without end.
  • At 7.0mag, a normal city would be shaken and see damage, but wouldn’t see the tens of thousands of deaths that Port-Au-Prince Haiti saw in 2010 when its multi-storey buildings pancaked.
  • The 2007 quake on the coast of Peru at Pisco was 8.0 and a very big one, but occurred in a place where most buildings are ready to take a big hit. So it’s worth noting that of the 430 people who were killed in the region  that evening (not the town, but the whole region), 148 were in the old and un-proofed Pisco cathedral when its roof collapsed.
  • On the other hand the 8.8mag Bio Bio Chile in 2010 was simply massive, the 6th largest recorded in modern times and affected some densely populated zones. Chile reported 370,000 damaged buildings and although 550 dead is 550 too many for comfort, it’s also tribute to building standards there that the total wasn’t counted in the tens of thousands; and that 550 total included tsunami victims unfortunately located at sea’s edge at the wrong time.

Examples ad infinitum, those three were off the top of my head as recent examples (plus a quick check on wiki to get the accepted numbers), historians can tell you about the Huaraz or Mexico City or Colombia quake disasters from which you’re bound to hear much the same refrain. That Cusco region quake last night was little more than a tremor by normal standards, this very office from where these words are being written has felt several of that sized movements in the last couple of years and they’re not a concern, they’re part of the way things are. Once you realize the movement is small and not building into something greater, nary a second thought is given bar the “oh, did you feel that one?” conversations you might have with acquaintances the next day. But if you live in Paruro Cusco a 4.8mag is no laughing matter, especially this morning, and that’s because adobes are fragile, heavy, kill people and leave them without roofs.
The moral of the story is simple: If you live in a quake zone, sleep in a well-built house. Overly wordy quake rant finished, have a pleasant and undisturbed Sunday.

Leave a Reply