IKN

Take physic, pomp

Ecuador: The Girón mining referendum soap-opera (from IKN512)

A segment from this weekend’s edition of The IKN Weekly, IKN512, in which we attempt to explain why the Azuay referendum vote set to happen this Sunday March 24th is important to INV Metals (INV.to), to the region around it and to the mining industry all over Ecuador.


xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx





Ecuador: The Girón mining referendum soap-opera

We need to catch up on what’s been
going on around the “popular consultancy” referendum in the Girón canton of
Azuay, South Ecuador. As reported on these
pages no end of times, this is the vote scheduled for March 24th
that has been officially sanctioned by Ecuador’s electoral body (the CNE)
and in theory at least, will decide whether the zone allows mining to go ahead.
This is a direct threat to INV Metals (INV.to) and its Loma Larga
(ex-Quimsacocha) project located in the zone.

First, what happened last week and
as reported on the blog (3) on Wednesday a judge in the capital Quito ruled that
the vote could not go ahead (4) as it did not yet have a judgment or ruling on
its validity from the country’s Constitutional Court. The ruling was quickly
celebrated by the country’s Vice-Minister of Mining in radio shows the next day
and also by INV.to.  As reported by
Canaccord in a note to clients, here is how INV CEO Candace MacGibbon reacted
to the news of the suspension:

Ms.
Candace MacGibbon, CEO, stated, “We are very pleased that this decision
ensures the rights of the Local Group and those of our surrounding communities
are upheld and respected. We are encouraged that the Constitutional Court will ultimately
determine the constitutionality of the referendum using the appropriate legal
process provided for within Ecuadorian law and that the referendum will be
suspended until such time.

Which sounds and fine and dandy,
but of course the real reason that INV and the pro-mining government were happy
about the suspension is that they know that if it went ahead, the anti-mining
side would almost certainly win. Local politicos have estimated that the vote
will go 70% to 80% in the anti’s favour and that sounds right on to me. But at
that point (and being unversed in the finer points of Ecuadorean law) I too
thought that the pro-mining lobby in Ecuador along with the obvious support of
the Moreno government had run a ring around the anti-mining lobby and the local
activists, that the referendum would not go ahead and the whole issue was set
to be caught in legal limbo, where the vote could not go ahead.

However, Friday brought a big
turnaround to the story when the CNE ruled (5) that the judge in Quito had acted illegally
in suspending the vote. Not only that, but his ruling was in flagrant violation
of the country’s election laws, to the point where the CNE are now demanding
his resignation as a sitting judge. The President of the CNE has asked the body
that rules over all legislative bodies, the TCE, to kick out the judge (6) and
the TCE has already agreed with the CNE’s argument on this. It now looks as
though the judge, somehow “persuaded” by either/or mining world and government,
tried to force through a ruling to scupper the referendum at the last minute
and ignoring the statute which says (and is extremely well-known in Ecuador)
that no legal body can affect the running of an election once the official
election period has begun. Here’s what the president of the CNE said on the
subject (7) (translated):

“When we in an electoral
process, no outside authority to the organization can intervene, directly or
indirectly, with the electoral processes nor in its functions. The electoral
process is ratified and will continue to March 24th, according to
everything as planned in the calendar.”

The bottom line is that the
referendum in Girón will go ahead next Sunday, March 24th, and it
will be a massive surprise if the anti-mining side loses. What happens then is
anyone’s guess, though I strongly suspect the pro-mining side (which includes
the national government) will argue that the result is invalid because a
locally-made decision cannot supersede national law. However, by that time the
officially sanctioned vote will be in the books and on the record, providing
highly significant backing for the local communities who have opposed the
project for literally decades. How any mining company can claim support for its
project after such a vote is beyond me, a prerequisite for permitting and
approval in Ecuador.

In the end, the government of
Ecuador is worried that Loma Larga will be blocked (one of the five official
strategically important mine projects) but is far more worried that the
upcoming vote create a precedent in Ecuador for referendum-type votes on mining
projects. This is the reasoning they used in the fight against the referendum and
it’s also something they pointed out during the 24 hours last week when it
seemed the vote wouldn’t happen. On this score I have plenty of sympathy with
the Lenín Moreno administration because even though they have made a big
mistake in trying to ram through an unpopular project against the will of the
local community, the can of worms it now opens will potentially affect every
mining project in the country. It will certainly be used by every single
indigenous pressure group and anti-mining NGO as a weapon against progress and
new developments.

Leave a Reply