Reader, friend and switched-on dude about miners, ‘B’ mailed your humble scribe today by forwarding the newly-minted 4q11 production NR from First Majestic (FR.to) (AG) and adding his own question at the top, “Does the Ag recovery surprise you?”
No ‘B’, it doesn’t. Check out these charts, dude. This first one shows the quarterly recovery rates posted by FR.to in 2010 and 2011 and to put it simply, they’ve always sucked but recently they’ve been getting worse. However, the tonnage throughput expansions at the company hide this fact because nobody gives a damn about efficiency when the bright shiny production numbers keep going up, right?
This second chart is a bit busier, but it’s readable enough. It shows the breakdown of recovery rates at the three FR.to mining operations (i.e. La Encantada, La Parrilla and San Martin) and also throws in the consolidated average again to give reference.
So by staring at this, it’s clear that La Encantada is the drag on recovery percentages. That mine ran at a pitiful 44% in 3q11 and we’re estimating (by the global recovery average that was announced early today) that La Encantada will return the same type of number in 4q11 too.
And the real problem is illustrated in this final chart, that shows just how much of overall production at FR.to comes from La Encantada. In 3q11 it supplied 66.23% of all silver ounces and we’re guesstimating the same type of number from 4q11 too.
Ladies and gentlemen, La Encantada is seriously underachieving on its recovery levels. But dammit, this is the golden boy of all silver mining ops right now! This is First Majestic! How dare a pissant upstart lil blogger criticize a stock like this?
You’re right, I shouldn’t touch the wondrous FR.to with my filthy, rotten, ill-wrought words. So instead I’ll quote directly from the FR.to 3q11 MD&A and leave it at that:
“Under ideal conditions with the revised mix of fresh ore and tailings [in 4q11], this plant [La Encantada] should be able to achieve 60% recovery rates”
dyodd, dude


