IKN

Take physic, pomp

Guatemala thoughts

Longtime reader and thoroughly good egg ‘RK’ writes in today and this extract from his mail below lays out the reason for the missive:

“I am interested in your assessment of the political risk in Guatemala. I own Tahoe Resources and like everything about the company (although it’s kind of expensive to add to now, I bought it substantially cheaper), but I am concerned about political risk.”

Well, in fact I haven’t mused or cogitated on Guatemala here at the blog for a while, but it is one of the regions we keep an eye on quite closely in the Weekly and the last time it got a mention was in IKN133 dated November 20th (a week and a half ago). So here you go RK, below is what got published that day in the subscription thingy.

Guatemala thoughts and Radius Gold (RDU.v)
Above we mentioned Firestone Ventures (FV.v) in a quick update of our Zinc Basket integrant and noted that met results for its small but decently grading Torlon Hill came in positively last week. One more thing needs to be taken into consideration as regards FV.v though, and that’s its country risk profile, as the most advanced projects at FV.v are in the Central America state of Guatemala.

I’m on record as saying the country should be avoided for its high political risk factors (including general political stability, problems in permitting to production stage, anti-mining undercurrents at local levels etc) but I’m also a realist and can see that Guatemala may get some sort of improvement (or perhaps better said, commentators that talk their books promote what they see as improvement just about to come) due to the recent election of right-wing Otto Perez Molina as President. The meme we’d expect is that Perez Molina is pro mining because he said he was and so as soon as he gets into power, Guatemala becomes this instant pro-mine region. That’s unlikely, as even if Perez Molina makes all the right noises there are innumerable problems faced by any mine operation to be in the country (just start with the low and high level corruption rife in the country and work down). But no matter what I think, more important is what the market collective thinks about Guatemala as mining country in the near future and, no matter whether eventually right or wrong, we may see a new chapter in optimism about the place.

These comments apply to FV.v of course, but also apply to other exploration stage juniors with projects in the country. First among those is Tahoe Resources (THO.to), the company exploring and developing the Escobal silver project there. Be in no doubt that the rocks at Escobal are exceptionally good ones, with vein widths, extensions and grades that all point to the best type of world class mine potential. The rocks have never been in doubt, but I get all giddy thinking about a junior with a $2.6Bn (with a B) market cap that’s exposed to the vagaries of a country as unstable as Guatemala. I suppose the thing I want to say here is that I’m more in tune to risking a few very high risk shekels on a microcap play such as FV.v than I am putting serious money down and making an investment in THO.to, because both have the same type of political risk to contend with but one of them might end up making you very poor (while the other loses you a chunkette of fun money).
 

The other play that comes to mind, and another that makes more sense to your author than THO.to, is Radius Gold (RDU.v), Simon Ridgway’s mothership company that has plenty of exposure to Guatemala. However this time the exposure is leavened by also having exposure to the eminently miner-friendly Nicaragua as well as Yukon assets (though those are getting spun out soon). The other thing we like about RDU.v right now is clear from this two year price chart; the stock price is at a low ebb with Friday’s close of 33c back at the levels seen in 2010 before RDU started fizzing and popping up to nearly a Loonie. RDU has lots of moving parts and isn’t a company that rests on its laurels, so a bit of risk cash here, especially as the entry price is appealing compared to just a couple of months ago, wouldn’t be the worst high risk trade you could consider right now.
 

The bottom line here that my personal call isn’t going to change and i still say “avoid Guatemala”. However, high risk money may feel like a flutter on Guatemala risk and potentially playing a new-found pro-mine feeling on the Perez Molina election. Who needs reality when you have perception, anyway? Of the three Guatemala vehicles mentioned here, RDU.v appeals the most and those into flippy type of trades (and as long as you go in with eyes wide open knowing that risk here is high) may want to consider it, tax loss selling season or not. FV.v is also a possible (see Zinc Basket) but is so tiny on a market cap level it brings its own risks. THO.to, for its sheer size compared to the others, scares me far more even though it’s got wonderful rocks and world-class mining potential.

Disclosure: No position in any mentioned company

Leave a Reply