IKN

Take physic, pomp

Here’s the thing about Quinton Hennigh

To get to the point, we are going to take as read that he is a world-class and peer-approved geologist, okay? I know that, you know that, good. My issue is that Quinton Hennigh the geologist has somehow managed to morph his stellar academic reputation into one that covers the world of business and finances as well, so it’s equally valid to judge him on what he has done to create hard coin wealth. That was the underlying point made as per the tweet this morning which turned into a fair debate with Brent Cook (who is both a friend of QH and a true objective professional admirer of his work, we have no problems there).
Companies create wealth away from capital markets and not in them, that is a basic truth. If your company, via innovation or discovery or whatever, brings new sources of wealth to the capital market arena it will create wealth for itself and those around us. And if it doesn’t it won’t, so the fact that Quinton Hennigh has not made a single economic discovery while in the junior arena means his companies have not created wealth. We also know the markets are a zero sum game and also that Quinton Hennigh has done very well for Quinton Hennigh. 
So if you really want to hero-worship a economic geologist, look somewhere else. For example David Lowell, a man who not only co-authored a highly significant geology paper (which is also without a shadow of a doubt the single most significant economic geology paper ever), but then went down the coast of South America, said “I think it would be a good idea to stick a big long drill hole in right here” and nowadays more copper comes out of the hole he made than the whole of North America. There’s a man who not only made himself justly rich and famous for his geological knowledge, but also created untold amounts of wealth for the planet, from shareholders of BHP to Chinese families with interior plumbing for the first time in their lives.

Leave a Reply