Last night, Southern Peru (SCCO) complied with the law, had its final “social audience” meeting with locals near to the Tia Maria project in the Islay region of coastal Peru and received its so-called “social licence”, a piece of paper it gets from the government which is a legal requirement for any mine project looking to get its key Environment Impact Permit approved. And as usual the whole process was one very large farce. In this case, it went something like this:
- Inside the meeting hall in the town of Cocachacra, 1,200 people assembled to hear SCCO do its thing. Which they did.
- Of those 1,200 people, those against the mine’s development were very thin on the ground despite the overwhelming majority of Islay locals being against the project. Also, those against the mine, including the local priest (not normally known for telling fibs) were adamant that the assembly was filled with people shipped in from locations outside Islay and were being paid to attend by the mining company. Just the same as in other meetings, in fact.
- But even then, there was no sort of vote or formal public approval process. According to the justice-seen-to-be-done artificial Peru system, all SCCO has to do is give its presentation and hold its meeting, no sort of yea or nay decision is required, looked for or received. The people inside the hall may as well have been mannequins.
- Meanwhile, outside the hall with 1,200 people were 2,000 police officers, fully equipped with riot gear, as well as a couple of riot containment vehicles (armour plating, water cannon etc). Their job was to keep thousands of real locals away from the hall; the protesters who are against the mine project weren’t allowed to attend the social audience meeting because we wouldn’t want to encourage a real debate at a meeting now, would we? Anyhow, the police did a good enough job (according to all media reports), with just a few skirmish-type incidents in outlying areas and a few tear gas canisters to upset the near-total success of the containment operation.
And so, Peru’s State news agency gets to trumpet the whole process, everybody happy, merry navidad and a prosperous año nuevo for all, right? And later down the line, when SCCO gets its EIA permit (because that’s a given now) everybody will swear blind that the locals approved of the mine plan back in 2013. They’ll also scratch their heads and wonder just why they’re all suddenly protesting against the development, blocking roads, causing mayhem etc when SCCO tries to start the build-out.
The bottom line is that there was no due process yesterday evening in Islay: Sure there was a nice bit of theatre designed to comply with a national law and there is a decent overtime payment or two for a bunch of police officers who just got their turkey paid for by Southern Copper, but any resemblance to the reality of Tia Maria and the true granting of local approval via a social licence that’s worth its salt was about a light year away. Thus ends another chapter of emerging market country* bliss.
*Can’t say 3rd world or banana republic any more: They don’t like it, or its out of fashion or something. Dunno why.