IKN

Take physic, pomp

IKN continues to be nasty to Sandstorm $SAND (article from IKN279, last weekend)

This was a section of The IKN Weekly issue 279, out last Sunday. Since this was published Luna Gold (LGC.to) has dropped nearly 10%.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Luna Gold (LGC.to)
underscores how Sandstorm (SAND) paid over-odds for shares
A classic Friday post-close bad news NR (18) from a junior
was delivered by Luna Gold (LGC.to) this week, here’s the body of the text:
VANCOUVER, BC–(Marketwired –
September 12, 2014) – Luna Gold Corp. (LGC.TO) (LGC.TO) (LGCUF)
(“Luna” or the “Company”) announces that as a result of
market conditions, it will not proceed with the second tranche of its
previously announced private placement totalling 10,500,000 shares.
The first tranche equating to
19,500,000 shares was closed on August 5, 2014.
As at September 1, 2014, Luna had a
cash balance of C$33 million, working capital of C$40 million and 7,000 ounces of
finished gold inventory.
At this point, we need to go back to the original placement
NR of August 5th (19) and here are two extracts for consideration:
VANCOUVER, BC–(Marketwired – August
05, 2014) – Luna Gold Corp. (LGC.TO)(LGC.TO)(LGCUF) (“Luna” or the
“Company”)announces a non-brokered private placement (the
“Placement”) of up to 30,000,000 common shares (the “Placement
Shares”) priced at $1.02 per share, for gross proceeds of up to $30,600,000.
…
Pursuant to the Agreement, Sandstorm
will purchase a minimum of 19,500,000 of the Placement Shares, for gross
proceeds of approximately C$19.89 million
In other words, Sandstorm (SAND) agreed to pick up nearly
2/3rd of the placement at $1.02, but just a month and a bit later
LGC.to has cancelled the rest of the placement and that’s because the share
price has done this:

LGC is down to a Friday close of 85c [EDIT: This chart now updated to Thursday 18th September, 77c close] and there aren’t many
entities that are going to pay $1.02 for something they can buy on the open
market at an 18.6% discount [EDIT: Now 24.5%]
Regarding Luna Gold (LGC.to), it’s a company that’s
promised much, delivered poorly and one I’ve always found easy to avoid. Its
descent hasn’t ever come as much surprise to this desk (it was a $3+ dollar stock even after the moment that the gold price
made its big waterfall drop in early 2013
) and though I’m keenly aware of
my own bad calls on other stocks in the period, at least in this case the avoid
call was obviously the right one.
Regarding Sandstorm (SAND), things are more complicated. At
face value the streaming model is an interesting one to follow in these lean
years (look no further than Franco Nevada or Silver Wheaton for your evidence)
but the latest decision to double down on LGC and get such an immediate thumbs
down from the market for the investment (term used loosely) call again calls
into question the judgement of the people running this shop (Nolan Watson at
the helm, but there are obviously others involved with the decision making
process). Also, it must be noted that we’ve already SAND buy into get hit and
then double-down on a story with too many similarities to be ignored, that of
Colossus (ex-CSI.to). The list of gold, Brazil, promising story, SAND
investment, things go wrong, SAND doubles down, things go even worse is
uncanny, also because of the political risk angle at the Colossus Serra Pelada
project and the foreign capitals’ total inability to read the political and
community risk situation correctly. That one has turned out very badly for
SAND, but that hasn’t deterred the same company that’s supposedly a streamer
from buying more shares in a troubled company it’s already exposed to and investing
into the asset side of another Brazil-exposed junior with obvious operational
issues (and several political ones too,
if persistent hearsay about is to be believed
).
Here’s a 2014 year-to-date chart that features SAND next to
fellow gold streamer, the more established and sector leading Franco Nevada
(FNV) as well as the junior PM ETF (GDXJ) as benchmark [EDIT: Also re-set to Thursday 18th September]. Even after resetting at
zero on January 1st 2014 after the debacle of Colossus in late 2013,
SAND is now underperforming both FNV and GDXJ after being ahead (and sometimes
way ahead) until August came along. The common denominator is the LGC deal,
which smacks of the market moving from love to hate about the aggressive
investment tactics at SAND.

For sure aggression is how empires are built, the winner
CEO is the one that takes chances. But SAND’s method would stick out like a
sore thumb in these prudent times even if the bets made by Watson et al had
been successful. Colossus hasn’t, neither was its first tranche of LGC, now its
second tranche has been given an immediate fail mark. To what point will the
current management of SAND be allowed to squander the profits of the successful
streaming model on unsuccessful equity wagers?

Leave a Reply