This was part of IKN700, out last weekend. The original plan was to make a brief note of the MRE upgrade announced by Marimara Copper (MARI.to) last week in the notes of the section we dedicate to copper sector coverage, but as things turned out the new resource came with too many new doubts to ignore or brush aside. So the short note turned into something longer, as seen here.
Marimaca Copper (MARI.to): We have questions
This note was originally slated for the Copper Basket section of today’s edition, but as the need to go into at least some detail grew, it ended up down here. The morning of Thursday October 13th saw Marimaca Copper (MARI.to) release its “…updated Mineral Resource Estimate (“MRE”) for the Marimaca Oxide Deposit (the “MOD” or the “Project”) located in the Antofagasta region of northern Chile” (30). Here’s how MARI presented the headline data:
- 98% increase in M&I Resource tonnes to 140Mt at 0.48% CuT for 665.5kt of Contained Copper
- 92% growth in Inferred Resource tonnes to 83Mt at 0.39% CuT for 322.9kt of Contained Copper
- Marimaca Confirmed as One of the Largest Copper Discoveries in the Last Decade
There was plenty of bullish and upbeat script in the NR (as you’d expect), with the CEO making plenty of the resource size all-but doubling At first read-through the numbers looked solid and the market seemed to agree, as these two price charts indicate. First is a three-month chart comparing MARI to the main copper producers’ ETF (COPX) and while trading has been choppy, since mid-September the stock has managed to beat peers handily. Then below is the ten-day hourlies chart that shows a little of that choppiness in close-up, but also how the price reacted positively to the MRE NR on Thursday, albeit on continued low volume.


However, as I started to look more closely more than a few doubts started to creep in and as this is The IKN Weekly, it’s the right place to be critical of what was presented as a “near doubling” of resource to the casual observer. We begin by considering what the resource count looked like until last week, via this table from previous corporate literature:
THE OLD RESOURCE COUNT AS PER 2019

This resource was used for the December 2019 PEA and itself was a near-doubling of the company’s original resource for Marimaca. By using a 0.22% CuT cut-off in 2019 they got the following numbers:
- Measured + Indicated: 70,387,000 tonnes at 0.60% Cu = 931.1m lbs copper
- Inferred: 43,105,000 tonnes at 0.52% Cu = 494.2m lbs copper
- Total contained copper: 1425.3m lbs Cu
For the record, we base our calculations on the overall copper grade (CuT) and not the grade of copper calculated as soluble in acid (CuS), as the company runs with the CuT number and uses it in its PEA and economic calculations with the requisite lower recovery assumption (76%). So far so good, we now move to the new updated MRE as per last week:
THE NEW RESOURCE COUNT

The job here is to try to get as close to “apples to apples” as possible, so to begin we consider the 0.22% CuT cut-off line for the 2022 resource:
- Measured + Indicated: 113,517,000 tonnes at 0.54% Cu = 1,351.4m lbs copper
- Inferred: 60,431,000 tonnes at 0.47% Cu = 626.2m lbs copper
- Total contained copper: 1,977.6m lbs
Tonnages are up, grade has dropped slightly and the result is to add 552m lbs copper to the 2019 numbers at this cut-off. However, this time around MARI is promoting a new and lower copper cut-off grade of 0.15% CuT for the 2022, therefore we consider a second line at 0.15%:
- Measured + Indicated: 139,567,000 tonnes at 0.48% Cu = 1,476.9m lbs copper
- Inferred: 82,678,000 tonnes at 0.39% Cu = 710.9m lbs copper
- Total contained copper: 2,187.8m lbs
Indeed tonnages may have “nearly doubled” but, due to the lower copper grades in the input data, total contained copper is up by around 50% compared to 2019. That’s still okay, in fact it would be good as long as the other criteria work in-line, but it’s at this point a second line of doubt begins. Here’s a table that lays out the changes in pricing and cost assumptions for the mine and as you can see, MARI has done some heavy optimization compared to its 2019 PEA criteria:

Main points:
- The base case for copper has moved up from U$3.00/lb to U$4.00/lb
- The mining cost assumption is down by 49c
- The heap leach processing cost assumption is down by $3.06
- The Run-Of-Mine processing cost assumption is down by 85c
Those cost assumptions would be significant cuts (“optimizations”) compared to a 43-101-compliant PEA even if we didn’t consider the inflationary environment seen this year. They’ve also chosen a copper price of U$4.00/lb on which to base their economics and what’s more, there’s an apparent desire to save capex and op-ex strip by assuming pit slopes that start in the same range as before, but rising to a (literally) steep 52% in some zones and before we leave this point, a brief reminder that this part of a world is a significant seismic zone. I grant they have revised selling costs upward to 16c/lb Cu from 7c, but that’s more a case of changing an input number that was obviously too low.
To sum up, in the December 2019 PEA, MARI assumed an overall production cost of U$13.50/tonne, plus 7c/lb eventual selling cost on the copper production. And now, three years later with the inflationary environment we see around us and copper trading around U$3.50/lb, it chooses a U$4.00/lb base price to allow the cut-off to drop to 0.15% CuT and then assumes the same cost criteria at U$8.10/tonne, with 16c/lb selling costs.
All this while selecting a U$4.00/lb base case for copper and dropping the cut-off to 0.15% CuT? Sorry, this is too much to swallow without getting some detailed breakdown from the company and good explanations of either 1) why the PEA inputs were too high (normally a mine PEA is “the best economics you’ll ever see”) or 2) why last week’s assumptions are so much lower than before. As much as I like the Marimaca project and its theoretical economics (oxide copper at low altitude should work), all this smacks of too much optimization and pushing the envelope of project economics in order to capture as much copper tonnage as possible and get the grand total to over 2Bn lbs for the sake of a headline. I’m leery of buying into this NR and promotion and will stay that way about the company until we get the DFS at some point next year. After all, “At U$4.00/lb copper they all work” so why pay up for a $300m market capper and all the embedded equity premium when I can get the same economics at vastly better leverage from QC Copper (QCCU.v) at its $22m market cap? Frankly, I’m less enthused about MARI this weekend than I was before, no matter how many extra tonnes they managed to tack on.