During your humble scribe’s trawl through the mighty world of the interwebnetpipes today, a report from China’s State news agency was chanced upon that had a scream in its headline:
“Golly gosh and blinking flip, 12% is a lot“, thought your humble scribe, because remittances of monies from outside of Mexico to people who live there are an important part of the country’s overall economy. Also, as most of Mexico’s remittance money originates from the USA, a sudden big drop would suggest some change in the economic make-up of Mexico’s Northern neighbour. However once the surface is scratched, the data revealed and the context understood, there’s really much less than meets the eye to all this. For a start, that 12% drop is compared with the previous month of June 2012 and NOT July 2011 (which is always a more reasonable comparative). And that suspect headline data gets confirmed with a bit of the body of the Chinese report that states (translated), “The U$1,866.26m [remitted] in July 2012 is 1.65% less than the same month of 2011, when the figure came to U$1.897m“. So the real comparative difference is 1.65%, not 12%, which is the type of small fluctuation that can happen from an extra holiday day or Jan Brewer kicking out a bunch of illegals from Arizona. Whatever, 1.65% doth not a trend make.
So what about that month-on-month drop? Well for that we need a bigger dataset, so off we went to the Mexico Central Bank site and its page on remittances and a few kicks and an XLS download later, we made this pretty chart:
So the 12% drop is wholly seasonal and on the whole, things have been getting better as regards remittances to Mexico. We’re still not up to the heady days of 2006/7/8, but the trend has been gently upwards for the last couple of years, seasonally adjusted.
And today’s moral? Journalists are assholes who want you to read their headlines and swallow prejudices, even in China. Now there’s a shocker, eh?
