IKN

Take physic, pomp

Minera IRL (MIRL.cse): Accidentally or by design

This humble corner of cyberspace is pleased to report Minera IRL (MIRL.cse) today published its second corporate update to shareholders in the space of five days, which was nice of them and makes three for the year. Here’s the link and to make sure, here’s the whole thing:

MINERA IRL ANNOUNCES ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING AND REDESIGN OF ITS CORPORATE COMMUNICATION STRATEGY 

LIMA, PERU—(September 29 2020).-  Minera IRL Limited (the “Company”) (BVL:MIRL) (CSE:MIRL) announces that it intends to hold its annual general meeting on December 15 this year and that it will be filing and mailing the shareholder materials relating to that meeting in due course.

In line with the recent news release, the Company is taking steps to prioritize and improve its communications strategy. This is to better inform shareholders with details of its ongoing efforts to reach a negotiated agreement with Corporacion Financiera de Desarrollo (COFIDE) to secure the funds needed to commission its Ollachea gold mine, as well as on operations at its Corihuarmi gold mine during the COVID-19 pandemic.

The Company’s desire is to improve its shareholder communications infrastructure and provide its shareholders with a comprehensive understanding of the Company’s activities, recent events and relationships with key stakeholders that are driving the Company’s future. This will include improvements to the website, general corporate communications and updates, and better email and telephone communications with investors and others interested in the Company’s initiatives.

For more information please contact our CEO, Diego Benavides:

 Mail: diego.benavides@irl.com.pe

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION, PLEASE CONTACT:

Minera IRL Limited

Gerardo Pérez President         +51 1 418 – 1230

Diego Benavides  CEO and Director       +51 1 418 – 1230

There are several new things there:

  • Contact details of company executives that connect you to the company executives.
  • A nice friendly offer for the reader, be they an actual or potential shareholder, to use those contact details and find out from the people at the top what is going on.
  • A long-overdue initiative to improve corporate communications, improve channels and image etc
  • The date set for the company AGM.

The first two are obviously related and a welcome turn of events. As for the third, the innovation that took up most space in the NR today, a cosmetic improvement is welcome at the company and I do not mean that lightly or ironically; MIRL needs to up its game and the sooner it gets some professional help in for its website and corporate visibility, the better. However we also need to be clear, cosmetic implies adornment rather than substance and it’s a little late in the day to think mere window dressing will put things right at the company.

Especially as we now have the clock ticking on the December 15th AGM. This news is more important than any of the above and here’s why that is (or perhaps, why that might be). To start, be clear that I do not care, for the moment at least, whether the latest 30 day delay announced by Minera IRL to its never ending saga with COFIDE a few days ago came about accidentally or by design. However, what is certainly true is that if MIRL and COFIDE had kept to this already-delayed time limit for negotiations, by the end of this week we would have received notice of the agreement and known its contents. But no, we now wait until end October and that’s interesting, considering that MIRL today called the AGM date, because within a lick and a spit on the precise dates 1) from today’s notice, you have to be a shareholder in two weeks’ time to vote and 2) more importantly, in one month maximum MIRL sends out the AGM circular materials, proxy, agenda items etc.

Before the proxy is out, matters such as relevant agenda items are up for debate, but once out the only way to go against management is to vote item(s) down or propose an alternative proxy slate, with all the contested AGM nonsense that goes with either option. Therefore consider that, accidentally or by design, if COFIDE/MIRL had kept to the original timeline we would now have around a month to consider the proposed deal before the AGM materials were sent out. We shareholders would be able to come to a considered opinion on whether or not the deal was good, and act accordingly. Also, third parties interested in the Ollachea mine would have had time to consider the deal structure, in which COFIDE will almost certainly be mandated the role of lead financier again, and perhaps offer a better alternative, all that comfortably before the December AGM. However, accidentally or by design, that opportunity now seems to be less clear as MIRL today called the AGM on September 29th and seems set to publish its proxy and agenda items either before or at almost exactly the same time as announcing the contents of the COFIDE deal. This means, to all intents and purposes, that not only will any third party have an impossible task to do the necessary DD in time to form a reasonable opinion and make an offer, but the AGM agenda items in the proxy are a black box.

All this is relevant to MIRL today and it becomes very relevant when you realize that I have been asking CEO Diego Benavides to answer a simple question since last Saturday. His idea of treating shareholders with respect is ignoring them, avoiding them and insulting them (had all three since Saturday, thanks Diego) and when he says that he welcomes questions from shareholders, that should say he welcomes questions he wants to answer because he’ll just blank you otherwise. Here’s what I’ve been wanting to know, word for word:

Do you plan on announcing the 2020 AGM, forwarding circulars, proxy material etc before or after the October 31st deadline with COFIDE?

Not a difficult one to answer, it’s a straight yes/no, but since Saturday afternoon CEO Benavides has steadfastly refused to answer the question despite being asked on multiple occasions, by ignoring it, avoiding it or answering with something completely different that suits him. Now for sure we don’t know, but it sure starts to look as if accidentally or by design we will have the AGM organized and the agenda settled upon before we know the outcome of the COFIDE negotiation. If COFIDE is then ratified with the mandate at the AGM, there will be no further opportunity for any third party to come in to add potential value and the door is shut for good.

Which means, accidentally or by design, shareholders could end up missing an opportunity during the window between the COFIDE deal announcement and the AGM. Accidentally or by design, COFIDE may turn out to be the only game in town after a extremely delayed and overly secretive negotiation and then we are required to vote not on the money arriving, but on giving COFIDE the job of putting the capex together. Perhaps at U$1,500/oz gold that didn’t matter much, but we are now in a different world where a lot of good projects become great and, as MIRL at Ollachea works at U$1,300/oz gold once the mine is operational after its inexpensive capex build-out, it becomes a licence to print money. I haven’t held onto my shares all this time because I like the social cachet that comes with being a gold mine investor, I bought and I’ve stayed in for a long time because I know how much that mine is worth (hint: many multiples of the current MIRL mkt cap). With gold where it is, I for one would at least like to hear if any other deal could add better value. The proposal is simple, to have same the playing field that the market would have had before the COFIDE announcement was delayed, accidentally or by design, as it has been tied up in a black box for way too long. I’d like other companies to review it and see if they can do better, as the whip hand changes with gold at these prices. In so many words, I want to know this COFIDE mandate isn’t going to be railroaded at me via an AGM agenda question. We shareholders have waited for endless years for a deal, the very least MIRL can do is give us a quarter to review it, give other companies the opportunity to use good ol’ fashioned capitalism and come up with a better deal if there is one, and then vote on giving COFIDE its mandate in an EGM in January 2021.

All this of course if, accidentally or by design, MIRL decides to push for a quick resolution. If it doesn’t and allows us ample opportunity to review the proposal, then so much the better.

13 Comments

    Rob My bathroom 30/09/20 12:42 am

    Can we get Lion One metals to own their recent post mkt Friday afternoon memory hole press release as well? Sold half my position to the Brainless HoseMan over this and my explorco self imposed “time stop”. Two comp. owned drills and they got 1 1/2 holes to show for a 40 million + raise?

    Pretty sure the bones of the agreement have been in place since February. MIRL and COFIDE could come out right now if they really wanted to, but they are fiddling with the clock.

    Pretty sure the bones of the agreement have been in place since February. MIRL and COFIDE could come out right now if they really wanted to, but they are fiddling with the clock.

    i should lodge an enquiry complaint with the Ontario Securities in advance so any deal be considered/reviewed by such in light of shareholder fair disclosure

    They’re trying. Better than a week ago.

    whatever whit I puked in here this morning wasn’t posted. and I don’t even remember what it was

    Would it be feasible for one of the larger shareholders to prepare a plan B proxy slate in case the agreement with Cofide is suboptimal for shareholders (but maybe by accident or design, very positive for the executives).

    As well, what happens if the agreement with Cofide is not ratified by shareholders? How much time would be available for a new executive to find another financing option? Could the courts impose a delay in Cofide taking aggressive negative financial action on short notice due to the extraordinary delay in coming to a first agreement?

Leave a Reply