IKN

Take physic, pomp

Regarding Tia Maria

From IKN530, out last night:



Peru: Tia Maria hype
On a PR
level, President Vizcarra’s handling of the Tia Maria construction licence
affair has been mediocre at best, which is surprising considering he was the
one (With Governor of Moquegua) who managed a successful negotiation between
the people of the region and the Quellaveco mine owned by Anglo American. His
main error was to have talked up a visit to the zone of influence around the Southern Peru (SCCO Tia Maria project by either himself
of his Prime Minister, only to abandon that plan and issue the construction
licence anyway. The main message to the Islay locals that “we little choice but
to approve the permit, but there will be no construction until a consensus is
achieved locally” has been scuppered by his non-appearance locally, summed up
by Arequipa governor Elmer Cáceres who, when asked whether either he or locals
were willing to sit down and talk, replied (translated) (18), “If they’ve granted the construction licence,
what are we going to have a dialogue about? We demand, as the region of Arequipa, that the
construction licence be annulled. If it is, then we can sit down and talk. As
long as it is not revoked, what are we going to talk about?
” He has a
point, as SCCO could if they wish ignore both national government and local
resident, just plough ahead and (try to) build their mine. Really wouldn’t be
advisable, though. Unsurprisingly the government replied that the permit was
irrevocable (technically true, but this is South America
and anything can happen) so we have immediately fallen into a deep impasse,
both sides entrenched and unlikely to speak to each other directly in the weeks
to come. Cáceres is my idea of a bad governor (see IKN Weeklies passim), so
it’s downright foolish of Vizcarra to have offered up such an easy political
advantage to him.
However, as
noted last weekend context is required. The enemies of the current government
(and there are many) are trying hard to make Tia Maria into some sort of inflection point in the Peru
mining sector and hyping it as the last chance for the country. They say if it
fails, the mining sector will fall into complete inertia and that’s utter
balderdash and nonsense. Tia Maria has been a no-go for the last eight years
and that’s not going to change, neither will it stop other projects from
becoming operating mines in the years to come including Mina Justa and
Quellaveco  (currently being built), then
add the development we’ll see in the Cajamarca region over the next five to ten
years, that’s without even checking the Peru Mining Ministry website.
Tia Maria
is a major issue, yes, but it’s first and foremost an issue for SCCO which has
backed itself into a corner with unspeakably bad CSR policies over the years.
Above and beyond the eight locals who have died in separate clashes during
protests over the years there (and locals are very quick to remind you of that
fact), let us consider the way in which the SCCO management said in 2015 that
those opposed to the project were “anti-mining terrorists” and the same person
in 2018 noted that the zone was the birthplace of Abimael Guzmán, leader of the
Sendero Luminoso extreme left wing terrorist group that murdered countless
thousands in the 1980’s and 1990’s, and that “there must be something in the
genes there”. Accusing any group of terrorism is serious stuff, doing it in a
place like Peru
is triple trouble. It is of course also political issue, a hot potato for the
government, a football to be kicked back and forth between the sitting administration
and its opposition. However it is not some sort of nemesis for the Peru
mining sector, never has been and never will be. Context, please.
PS: This
Sunday morning, the latest Ipsos survey shows the approval rating for President
Martín Vizcarra down from 50% to 44% (19). The main reason for the change is a
precipitous 20 point drop in his approval in the South of the country, from 56%
in June to 36% today, with the principle reason cited being his (mis)handling
of the Tia Maria permitting issue. His approval rating rose slightly in
Lima/Conurbation (from 49% to 52%) but fell in all provincial macro-regions,
which in itself is an indication of the political split of the country. He also
polls most strongly with the higher level socio-economic groups (A+B), lowest
with the levels (D+E). Sadly, we’ve seen this movie before. The 2021
presidential election campaign will bring interesting times to Peru (in the
Chinese proverb way).

Leave a Reply