IKN

Take physic, pomp

The Rio2 (RIO.v) EIA for the Fenix project has been denied by the government of Chile

This is scandalous. This is the link. This is the contents.

VANCOUVER, British Columbia, July 05, 2022 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Rio2 Limited (“Rio2” or “the Company”) (TSXV: RIO; OTCQX: RIOFF; BVL: RIO) and its Chilean subsidiary, Fenix Gold Limitada (“Fenix Gold”) announce that the Regional Evaluation Commission which includes 12 governmental institutions has voted for not approving the Environmental Impact Assessment (“EIA”) for its Fenix Gold project in Chile.

Following this decision, the Company will work on evaluating its options and decide on an action plan. Once the action plan is completed, the Company will announce how it intends to execute it and provide the revised timeline. It is important to highlight that Fenix Gold remains with the conviction that it has provided enough technical information and studies to obtain a favorable EIA decision. This is well supported by the position from the Environmental Assessment Service (“SEA”) with the following favorable key considerations:

The Project fulfills all the applicable regulations and meets the environmental requirements for the granting of applicable sectorial permits.

Fenix Gold has satisfactorily completed the 1) Participación Ciudadana (Citizen Participation) and 2) Consulta Indígena (Indigenous Consultation) processes.

The Fenix Gold Project is an example of modern gold mining where a full complement of technical, environmental, and social considerations have been consulted on and designed in from the outset. The Project represents a significant investment in the gold mining business in Chile by a junior mining company and will generate employment for approximately 1,200 people during the construction phase and 550 people during the 17 years’ operations phase. The mine being contemplated at the Project will be a run-of-mine heap leach operation, no crushing or tailings storage facilities are required thereby minimizing the overall impact and footprint of the project.

ABOUT RIO2 LIMITED

In that NR, this segment is the most informative:

“…Fenix Gold remains with the conviction that it has provided enough technical information and studies to obtain a favorable EIA decision. This is well supported by the position from the Environmental Assessment Service (“SEA”) with the following favorable key considerations“

Or in other words, Chile has made a political decision to block a mining project that complied with the country’s own technical criteria. That means bad news not only for RIO.v, but for any mining company moving a project forward in the country. The message is clear: “Whatever you do, we won’t give you your permit.”

PS: For daily mailer readers seeing this on Wednesday morning, the comments section has more thoughts. Feel free to add your own and throw a few brickbats if so desired, just keep the language clean.

54 Comments

    “same idiots who tried to scare you out of Chile’s mining sector”

    But what of the idiots that scared me out of Chile’s mining sector…
    https://iknnews.com/chile-and-mining-nationalization-toldyaso/

      That is about the Constitutional Assembly vote. If you want to lump it in with this you can, but it’s a separate process.

      FWIW, the referendum on the change in Constitution comes in September and opinion polls in Chile say between 28% and 33% will approve the new Constitution, between 52% and 57% will reject it.

        That vote in September will probably be the next catalyst for Rio2 though, no? Do you expect anything to happen before then?

          The appeals process includes going to the national Ministerial Committee (i.e. 6 sitting ministers), the same track now being used by Anglo for Los Bronces.

          If the referendum is struck down, it will change the political dynamic in Chile. By how much at the national ministerial level is up for debate.

    Were there any reasons given?
    Are there any links where I can read the minutes of the meeting or get the panel’s take on why it was rejected?

      I assume the minutes (Acta) will appear on this link, the one dedicated to the EIA process:

      https://seia.sea.gob.cl/expediente/expedientesEvaluacion.php?modo=ficha&id_expediente=2146327395

      Not there yet. FWIW i spent time reading through all the previous decisions made by all the Chilean bureau before the recent recommendation to reject. Up until then, they were all happy with the EIA process and what the company was doing, approval letters abound from multiple desks including the regional SEA office. Then the new national SEA office got involved, and…

      However bad this decision is (and it is, for RIO.v and for the whole Chilean mining scene) it’s extremely difficult to blame Rio2 in this, they did everything asked of them, chinchillas included. So as much as it’s going to annoy people to read about somebody sticking up for the company, I’m going to stick up for the company.

        Anything to make of the distinction between « not approved » and « rejected »?

          I’m trying to find out more about the way the decision went down. Not sure the style is too important next to the substance today, but it will give an idea on what RIO.v has as recourse. There’s a clearly defined appeals process to follow, as well as layers of legal protection, so it’s not as if all is lost.

    A Beaten Down Prospectors Cabin In The Woods The Deep Dark Woods of British Columbia 05/07/22 8:58 am

    Snowline Gold (Yukon) doing well today even in this sell-down environment … money flow will increasingly head north due to risk aversion, as LatAm is essentially the new Africa, imo

    Chile basically saying we’re closed for resource development. Why would anyone spend a dime developing a resource in that country knowing that, despite fulfilling all the requirements the project can be cancelled on a whim.

    They wanted to stop this project, the chinchillas were just an excuse. Very obvious now.

    Could there be possibility that Alex didn’t handle EIA process best way possible? What if LA.V gets their permission?

      The EIA process in Chile is laid out and regimented, all sides know (or perhaps that should be *knew*) the rules, true for a mining project or any other large civil works project. To simplify but remain accurate, let’s consider just the country’s environment board (SEA) and those chinchillas:

      1) Company submits application
      2) SEA says “we want you to monitor for fauna”
      3) Company does so
      4) SEA “we want you to check for chinchillas”
      5) Company does so
      6) Now we want you to check for them over there, there and there.
      7) Company does so
      8) SEA “ok, those chinchillas you found in that one place, give us more information, make a detailed survey”
      9) Company does so

      Note for points 3) 5) 7) 9): in RIO.v case they went above and beyond the SEA requests and did more than asked, always using nationally qualified and recognized third parties (e.g. specialist environmental investigation people). They also provided expert opinion that the animals monitored were outside the project area of influence (again third party and not just a bunch of mining blokes going “no problems we promise”). Also re. point 9), at that point the regional SEA desk handling the permot request was also satisfied with the information gathered. There was zero dissent from the Chilean authorities regarding the work done from 2020 until three weeks ago.

      And this is the thing: The Chilean environmental people can ask you for any and all the information they want and that’s fair enough. The company complies with the requests. That is how EIAs are permitted in the country, the rules are (*were*) clear for both sides. This is why the Chile decision today is scandalous, they’ve ripped up their own rulebook.

        I don’t think there was ever any doubt that the SEA was going to vote against Rio, NO MATTER WHAT. But there had to be a bunch of other groups voting against them, as well. I’d like to know who they were.

        fwiw, I think that Fenix has been made a sacrificial lamb. Its economic impact would not have been great, and it was in a scenic area. Some of the NO votes were probably virtue-signalling.

        If Chile is still open for mining, then Marimaca should easily get permitted.

    Trading now halted…

    This is terrible news — I’ll be very interested, of course, to see what the company has to say going forward. It sounds like it was a very quick decision.

    The stock seems to be halted now, for improper dissemination of news. Any idea on how long that is going to be for?

    Don’t slam the door yet. Au is not Cu. If we see this with an Atex resources down the road I would agree. Altitude may become a saving grace, fewer thing living at those heights. Of coarse they might get up in arms about a rare altitude only plant. We need to make tough decisions going forward as a species. It’s here where I hope the underlying metal being mined gets due consideration going forward. Golds use case is not as strong as Coppers. I know heresy, but it’s not

      The Los Bronces decision was about copper. That EIA denial was arguable for technical reasons regarding the dust it would produce contaminating local human population, but it raised suspicions of SEA intentions in the industry at the time. Arguably the Los Bronces rejection was not for spurious reasons, but this one is and is all the confirmation one needs, gold or not. They decided to reject, then looked for a reason.

    Any word on whether it was a flat out ‘no’ or if it was a ‘no, until you fulfill the following items’?

      We need the minutes for that to be certain. From what I’ve gathered, it was a “no”.

      If it were the latter, I would expect the company to have said so. Given what little they said, it seems the decision was worse than the worst case previously put forward.

        Given the speed with which this came out, which surprised me, is it possible that the company simply received the results without accompanying details? I might have misread Mark’s description of the process, but I’d understood there to be a discussion period later on. I agree that if it is simply a straight ‘no’, that is significantly worse than what I understood the likely range of outcomes to be.

        Will the notes include the voting totals as well?

          I suppose the vote totals will be included. The last set of minutes were published June 23rd for a June 22nd meeting, assuming the same this time. As for the exact way the “no” was handed down this morning, that’s the committee’s right.

    A Beaten Down Prospectors Cabin In The Woods The Deep Dark Woods of British Columbia 05/07/22 11:02 am

    Is this the new path to Nationalization? …..

    – deny permitting approval

    – property black-listed by the govt. & industry

    – drive mining co. in bankruptcy and out of the region

    – state miner eventually comes in and picks up the pieces for pennies on the dollar – and gets it permitted

    thirsty Mission Dolores 05/07/22 11:19 am

    Say, notice anything going on with Hecla and Alexco? Did Wheaton come out on top?

    Bullish oil and gas.

    Everyone talking going green but blocking mining projects.

    Yes this is a gold project, but…

    Politicians create policies to drive energy prices higher while slowing the needed metals for the transition? This ends with pitchforks.

    Trades filled before the halt this morning have been cancelled after being filled. Rio2 really made a pigs ear out of this. Alex Black has some explaining to do.

    Transporting water from Copiago to the Fenix Gold site would require 72 trucks ( 1 every 20 minutes) to start mining. This would then increase until full production. The environmental impact this would have on the area was always a big concern to me. I do not think they will get the license until they can find another way to get water.

      This is an example of why an EIA permitting track has rules and stages, it’s not as if this wouldn’t have occurred to anyone else. The company submitted its plans and got approval for every stage of water procurement, including the where and the how, the trucks, the use of roads etc, and even though there are zero residents in the vicinity there are 6 communities with terrains, so those conmunities were consulted and their approval obtained. True also for the Atacama govt (a group of people who care about water) and sure enough after two years of submissions, the company plans for water were approved by all regional govt bodies, green lights all the way.

      This is why the rulebook exists! We on the outside can have all the concerns and impressions possible, the permitting process is run by people who look into these aspects and make sure the company’s plans do indeed abide by the rules. And again, the scandalous nature of this Chilean govt decision needs underscoring because the company did everything asked of it. The rulebook was thrown out the window at the last minute by people who decided to refuse the project for ideological reasons, then looked for an excuse to do so. Even then the water plans passed muster, they used the fauna as the spurious excuse.

      This is also why I will stick up for the company despite having lost a lot of money (so far) as a shareholder. When you follow a company through a permitting track and watch it complete stage after stage in correct style, it’s normal to have increasing confidence about the eventual approval. Problems in an EIA procedure show up earlier, not later, and I as observer could see the milestones being hit and achieved all the way through. Water, land, contamination, etc etc, you name it. Rio2 complied with everything and the regional bureau agreed, so under normal circumstances (which the last three weeks certainly were not) the final approval is a rubber-stamping, a revision of approvals gathered. Instead in this case it was politicized by a national body sticking its oar in at the last minute. The dynamic of the company and the country also needs to be understood, the company must always respect its location inside a sovereign nation and comply with whatever asked of it. Over two years Chile asked and Rio2 complied, and when all issues are resolved to the satisfaction of the sovereign nation, EIAs are awarded. It’s how the system works (or in this case, worked) so annoyed as I am about this, I know where not to lay the blame.

        Al East York 06/07/22 6:06 am

        I do wonder whether or not low grade open pit gold heap leaching is a good idea especially given the comment about trucking water and the unsustainability of this type of plan. Once all of the technical information has been gathered and submitted the final decision making should be a gating item not a box ticking exercise, regardless of the process that has been followed. I’m not very familiar with the project so hopefully this comment is not off base. regards.

        For ideological reasons? I thought their ideology is to listen to the people who -as far as i understand- are very much for the project. Imagine some pro-mining protest now…the irony!
        If the SEA doesnt offer any path to solve that, then indeed ideology took over.

    Rio2 is tied to that location and SEA has a say in the process, whether one wants it or not. Understanding the frustration with the EIA process, a more constructive approach in the interests of the shareholders would be to negotiate with the SEA / other parties involved re animal protection. Rio2 seems to attack the authorities protecting/victimizing itself. This is unlikely to yield any results and will only hurt the shareholders.

    Firebrand personality’s can takeover an organization that has the right of refusal when things like this happen, yes ideological reasons. Often in these governmental sub organizations there is a person no one else wants to upset or get on the wrong side of, we all know them. Job security is the concern of most. But to the disruptive personality It’s emotional, a cause. Who is that person here? There’s clear abuse of power.

      We can only speculate here until we hear more from Alex and see the minutes. Maybe the SEA matter should have been dealt with more privately with the people opposing it? Was there lobbying by the supporters that didn’t go over well? Who were the others among the 11 that said No and why?

    As a shareholder one should care about making money, not about the ego of the individuals involved or politics. This is not tech but mining. It is tied to the location, the company will always be a hostage to the authorities. It is clear SEA bend the rules but didn’t break them. This happens everywhere. What shareholders should care about are not emotions but the team which can find the compromise, build the mine and make money. That’s it

    Is it possible that SEA local and/or National individuals were looking for a “donation” at the private/individual level to give their approval? I ask because I was born and raised in So America and that’s usually the way things work. As Mark pointed out I. The past, in the USA the process I called “lobbying”…

    Just wondering if this company has any value left at all or will it just trend down now to its intrinsic value – $0.

    At this point I’m assuming Chile is stealing the mine. Just took my 75% loss and am moving on to my other browning pastures.

    It may be a coincidence that today Solis announced they are dropping their option on the Chilean copper property they have been busily exploring in favour on concentrating on their Peruvian projects.

    Or maybe it isn’t a coincidence after all…

      Jason Cubitt, Solis’ president and CEO, stated: “Mostazal presented an exciting prospect for us with a known copper mineralised system at surface and historical data supported an exploration thesis testing deeper targets. However, results from our first phase of drilling and geophysical surveys undertaken by the Company in 2022 ultimately did not meet our minimum expectations and management determined that it is in the best interest of shareholders to re-allocate the Company’

    I’m curious — I looked at the site you referenced above for the Acta of the meeting, and found only a single document that essentially said ‘no comments’. Is that it for the guidance from Chile on what has happened, or do you think there is more to come?

      Still waiting for the minutes. That new document is a visacion (a “vision” or endorsement or sighting, i.e. “our office has read the documents” confirmation note and nothing of particular interest). The minutes will go under the title “Registro acta” or similar.

    Womp womp. Found this on twittter. Seems press down there is starting to publish about it.

    https://mineriaenlinea.com/2022/07/rio2-dice-que-el-eia-de-su-proyecto-de-oro-fenix-en-chile-no-esta-aprobado/

Leave a Reply