As subscribers of the Weekly know, on Monday I had a virtual meeting set up with Diego Benavides, CEO of Minera IRL. Within moments of the exchange starting, CEO Benavides informed your author that the September 30th* deadline for an agreement between the company and COFIDE was going to be extended for a month, to end October.
And that, more or less, was the end of the meeting. Not only was there little else to know, but the CEO of a publicly listed company was happy to casually offer up non-public material information. At that point I was compromised if the company didn’t issue a NR before trading and sure enough, the next morning no news release; this, apparently, was special information only for me. I can only imagine that Benavides, under the impression that he is Minera IRL, thought he’d found a cool way of disseminating information without having to go to the bother of being responsible and telling the market himself (his constant excuse about the lack of NRs this year is that “COFIDE wouldn’t like it”, which has always sounded false; the last time I looked COFIDE wasn’t a shareholder of the company).
Therefore Tuesday I didn’t even open my laptop, let alone turn it on, until trading was over. It was smarter to be out the house and away from the trading desk to make sure I couldn’t be accused of trading the information, but when the close came and still nothing from MIRL, I wrote what I wrote which included the strong suggestion that the stock should be halted. And it still should, because non-public material information has been divulged by the CEO of MIRL to a third party and the information imbalance still exists
What we need from MIRL is that NR which states the company and COFIDE have extended the deadline to October 30th. And with it, a bit of reassurance for shareholders that the company gives a toss about them and will stop fawning to the Peruvian State bank that LOST the arbitration against the company (though you’d hardly believe it, over a year later).
*In fact September 28th, as they stipulated 90 days.
UPDATE: Happy to inform that MIRL has finally published an NR. Hoorah it’s here. And if you haven’t worked it out already, “gentle pressure” = voting against the MIRL CEO in the upcoming AGM. Anyone feel like joining several shareholders covering several million shares and making a point about corporate governance?
what’s his email or phone? the one on the website is useless voice message. at least Pinto used to reply to emails lol.
Benavides is a slave to perfection (as defined by himself) is about all I can say now. He’s probably a B+ salesman as well. If what he says is true they aren’t sitting on their hands anyway. I think he misunderstands how important it is to follow the rules in North America, or at least be perceived to be following the rules anyway. Life is tricky when you adhere to one jurisdiction but need to comply with another jurisdiction. Also I believe his heart is in the right place.
Lindsay
Did you speak to him?
Yes. Ask Mark for his number. Diego happily gave me about 10 minutes. I didn’t get anything new. I told him to keep in mind there are real people here with real money sitting on his story for many years and please just follow the rules and get this done. Friendly enough. Mark can say what he thinks since he’s actually pressed fleshed with him. From what he says all will be ok. But I don’t know him so…
Thanks Lindsay. I hope he has more urgent business than to talk to me.
Thanks for the post Lindsay. Bottom line.Without a 3rd party COFIDE has us by the short hairs.Time is up.Open up the playing field!
It could be argued that publishing here would be as broad a dissemination as any of the alternatives open to the company? And possibly broader, while impacting company funds in a most ideal fashion?
He got the NR out about 45mins ago.
This might actually be the most divulgent NR since Hodges took over.
I‘m sitting on 850k shares for a few years now and assumed that Benavides was thankful enough to loyal shareholders that he „got his company back“. Apparently it seems that he cares a f%&§ about us and I‘m happy to join Mark in voting against Benavides in the upcoming AGM. Pathetic business behaviour relying on excuses.
I’m not saying anything about my numbers (plus all the family members and friends, and even a couple lawyers who like getting hurt when they aren’t doing their jobs) but those are rookie numbers. AGM is a ways a way. About Rio Tinto, at this point for them it’s probly a write off, not even worth paying a broker to get it floated. Just an out of money option now.
I see two main questions on this:
1. Does Benavides have the will and confidence to lead the company through the process of bringing a mine into production, or, is he too comfortable as a caretaker, ragging-the-puck as long as he can, while drawing outsized compensation for that role?
2. What does Rio Tinto think of this? It’s not a big number in their financials, but even small numbers draw the attention of the most senior management when expectations keep on being unmet.
Those are good questions, Robin.
Robin I believe Diego has the Will and the means to bring Ollachea into production myself and my fellow shareholders some 6 million shares will be voted for him, Mark I think you have over stated your remarks because you are angry and upset at another delay which as myself is understandable, in saying that I believe they are doing the best they can under the circumstances to resolve the situation and move forward..
I respectfully disagree. The circular dilemma outlined in this most recent letter indicating the need to resolve the mechanistic aspects of lien security and collateral issues first prior to obtaining the commitments of a third party lender are or should be easily solvable . This is not a gordian knot as depicted. This is legal/business negotiation deal structuring 101. This is Basic. It is not complex. Its really child’s play for competent attorneys.
All shareholders should sign up for their, promised bi-monthly newsletter.
Send you name and email address to: minera@irl.com.pe
Lets keep them honest by showing that we, the shareholders are watching!
Yes. I am in
Sorry, permit me to clarify. I am in with voting my shares with Otto to elect a new management slate. What’s needed here is an incentivised shareholder friendly management, not a comfortable mgmt seeking to maintain status quo and extracting comfortable salaries. That clearly isn’t working well for shareholders. 500k shares available and aligned with Otto’s group here.
Just finished reading the entirety of the comments. If the swinging dicks here think that 500k shares is bupkis, so be it. It’s what I have and it will add incrementally to what I expect will be a sizeable pile of weaponry for Otto’s slate..
Much agreement here. As for vote size, as somebody who knows the type of vote % numbers that MIRL can generate from a hotly contested AGM/EGM (i have watched two), I can promise that the number of votes already in soft alignment here is enough to give CEO Benavides a lot of food for thought before the Circular goes out.
Not trying to play like a BSD but Benavides has until the AGM to get this done. I’ll be against him if it’s not done and for him if it is. For now he has a month. You and hundreds of others with smaller counts matter too. And getting this done matters even more when it’s added up. There’s a town that needs the money too and Diego feels that heat too.
The time for trusting his word has gone. Sorry, but if you “believe him” you are now in a minority.
I don’t want anything special, simply normal corp governance and not this black box. Benavides has to go because he treats MIRL like his fiefdom
I agree! Count me in for 330k and then family and friends.Like someone mentioned “he’s ragging the puck” and collecting big bucks
I also agree and count me in for 100k. Ready for a new sh revolt.
Yes, my dusty old 600K shares may finally be put to use. At the same time, if he gets this done soon and the terms are reasonable, I could be forgiving, especially if he develops a new attitude about transparency….
How dependent is the agreement with the Ollachea community on Mr Benavides remaining in his current position?
500k shares asking.
I dont want Diego out, bc no Diego=no Ollachea. Community wont accept someone else. Some people tried, didnt work.
From last years circular, he earns 500000 USD/year (WTF?). Change that.
After the COFIDE deal they will need 2 more quarters to put up a financing. Hopefully they will work on their expectation management/transparency.
For five years it’s been “Diego = No Ollachea”. Where is the evidence that he is the kingpin in this project? All I see is stones in shoes.
Unfortunately true, have to agree with u. His trackrecord is ok for defending the company. Shareprice and development of Ollachea isnt.
After a deal with COFIDE most shareholders should be green. That might change sentiment.
I am still Team Diego. Not bc hes done great, but bc he is the least bad option right now.
At this point who cares. If we lose money, they lose money. It’s the principle. Going to be interesting to see who’s going to give them 500k USD a year after screwing up here. Certainly not this group of investors.
I’m 1M shares in. Will definitely vote against management.
Is Benavides a racist pig?
The Sealion is back! Knew you wouldn’t be able to resist, so easy to read minds like yours.
Found another 40k shares only bought this week.