IKN

Take physic, pomp

The Fed and that punchbowl (from IKN693)

The intro to last Sunday’s edition of the weakly:

The Fed and that punchbowl

“So we beat on, boats against the current,

borne back ceaselessly into the past.”

The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald

In last weekend’s intro “When in a Jackson Hole Stop Digging” we considered Jay Powell’s upcoming policy speech would be an important one. With the next FOMC set for the end of next month, Powell had the opportunity to jawbone the preferred Fed narrative and we even noted how he’d likely get a free pass even after last year’s “Transitory Inflation Only” debacle when he banged on his We Hate Inflation drum. Here’s a quick reminder from last weekend’s note:

 “…the Fed gets over a month to regain the narrative it prefers and as its whole focus is now on inflation suppression, we’re going to get that in spades on Friday. So summing up, this year’s Jackson Hole is more important than the average edition. We also know from last year’s event that the Fed’s stance can be dead wrong without there being much pushback, which gives Jay Powell yet another reason to jawbone hard. We should take care and assume the Plain Vanilla Recession scenario gains ground. That’s not good for metals in the near-term, no matter whether hard data coming in September points to the more likely stagflation scenario.

Indeed, the anticipation rose during the week and come Friday morning, the market sold off from the open as by then, the transcript of his speech had been published, no need to wait until 10am and the live show. We got the “DOW DOWN A THOUSAND!” headlines in non-trade press, we got everything that isn’t a USD selling off and sure enough, the carefully accrued gains of the week in gold (GLD) and the miners (GDX) GDXJ) vaporized into a waterfall:

Up to then the GDX(J) had been up 5% and enjoyed a constructive week, too. Sigh. So what gave the market the willies? Answer, pure jawbone and here are a couple of soundbites from the official transcript (1):

“Restoring price stability will take some time and requires using our tools forcefully to bring demand and supply into better balance. Reducing inflation is likely to require a sustained period of below-trend growth,”

“Moreover, there will very likely be some softening of labor market conditions. While higher interest rates, slower growth, and softer labor market conditions will bring down inflation, they will also bring some pain to households and businesses. These are the unfortunate costs of reducing inflation. But a failure to restore price stability would mean far greater pain.”

This fit snugly into the Standard Recession Narrative and over in the bonds market, the yield curve inversion steepened slightly (2). We had seen a reading of as low as -0.48% the week before last, that had recovered to -0.25% on Wednesday but by the time the Friday market had finished, we were back at -0.33% and while Jerome Powell made some half-hearted efforts to promote a potential soft landing, the likelihood of real recession is now baked in. This long-term chart is a reminder that every single yield curve inversion is duly followed by a recession period (grey shading) and, while that may be painted in retroactively, warnings of job losses and “some pain to households” did not go unheeded.

To use the modern vernacular, let’s unpack all this. The first point to make is that last Friday did not change anything in the real economy (underlined and bold-typed for a reason).

  • Before the speech, The Fed took the position of using its tools to combat the scourge of inflation using Whatever It Takes and Jay Powell.
  • Before the speech, the market countered that with “The Fed Pivot” narrative and said that talking the hardline policy was one thing, but when push comes to shove The Fed would be mad to deliberately drag the US economy into a deep recession with all the job losses that would entail, not least due to the timing of the electoral cycle.

After the speech, The Fed’s position hasn’t changed, neither has those who would fight them. What has changed is the market’s choice of which narrative to believe and as we now have a period of a few weeks before any serious policy decisions need to happen, the jawbone factor tipped the balance and the Head of the Federal Reserve snatched the proverbial punchbowl in the way demanded by his predecessors. So we can call him and his committee friends all the names we want and indeed, peddlers of doom or scandal mongering mountebanks they may turn out to be, or “he got it wrong last year, why believe him this time?” is also bound to make the rounds but it’s not going to take the nerves and fear away from the broad market, not for a while at least. We also know that while high, US CPI notched down last month from CPI +9.1% to CPI +8.5% and can be construed as the start of the correction period that the Fed wants to adopt. We also know that under the headlines, money velocity and credit availability has dried up and that business inventories are dropping, those are the type of macro data the Fed watches carefully to see whether policy is taking effect so they’ll be heartened by the initial response and ready to do more.

The major question that remains to be answered is the same one we’ve had from the start of this process and at some point, we will get more clarity on whether our future beholds Recession or Stagflation, but not today and not for September, either. Pure jawbone or not, Jerome Powell’s speech did what he wanted of it and this weekend, my phone’s push feed includes headlines such as “Powell’s Jackson Hole Speech Delivers A Fatal Blow To Markets”, or “A Recession Is Inevitable, Don’t Get Fooled By Bear Market Rallies” (two of Seeking Alpha’s Must Reads of the week, so I’m told). So yes it’s jawbone, it’s blather and it may turn out to be another bunch of phooey from a FedHead but for the next few weeks, reality will take a back seat to sentiment and the market will price in a classic recession scenario.

The bottom line: For my money (literally), there’s still no reason to dive back into this mining company sector with new or preserved cash. The very best case is that the week ahead proves me wrong, gold catches a bid, copper ignores the financial world’s perceived headwinds (see Copper Basket today, below) and rises on real world Chinese demand. In that case, waiting another week to see if Jay Powell’s message is rejected is common sense and we won’t miss much. However and as laid out above, the sense is that the Fed Jawbone will hold sway for at least until the next FOMC meeting and maybe further out than that. Whether real or fictitious, the jawbone seems to have done its job and the punchbowl is being snatched away before our very eyes. In fact, I’m probably closer to selling another position (or two) than adding anything extra, but that’s another decision that can wait at least a week. Style beats substance in this current market and my personal opinion that we’re in a commodity-supportive Stagflation scenario, rather than in commodity bearish Plain Vanilla Recession, is neither here nor there; for the next few weeks, The Fed’s jawbone looks set to rule the roost and push down prices of most things in USD terms.

Leave a Reply